Traffic jams: Not just a menace but also a loss

Posted on August 18, 2006
Filed Under >Bilal Zuberi, Economy & Development, Environment, Society
Total Views: 28625

By Bilal Zuberi

All city dwellers know the problem of traffic jams well, but when it comes to Pakistan, these traffic jams take on a unique meaning. Imagine the traffic, from trucks, cars, rickshaws, motorcycles and bicycles to horse carriages and donkey carts, all jammed up back to back (sometimes neck to neck) and cursing the moment they decided to take that road.

karachi traffic jam
Karachi sees traffic jams regularly and not too long ago I once again experienced being stuck in a highway parking lot on Sharah-e-Faisal, the main highway in the city. I was trying to rush to the airport but on that day a trip that usually takes under 20 minutes took me over 2 hours. Needless to say I missed my flight, but I also suffered spending over 2 hours in the high heat, humidity and soot & dust pollution on the road.

Traffic jams in Pakistan are not just a menace to those on the streets, they also impact the overall productivity of our society and are a real threat to our development. It is not unheard of for an office worker to be delayed by up to an hour for work, or be late for important meetings because of traffic jams. From official meetings to personal affairs such as wedding and other parties, the most common excuse for being late is being stuck in a traffic jam – and unfortunately it is often the real reason as well.

The economic and social cost to cities with regular traffic jams has been estimated by economists around the world and it is extremely high (not to mention the costs associated with environmental pollution generated by idling engines and stop & go traffic, the health problems created in the people breathing the undiluted exhaust emissions, and the reduction of property value in areas where traffic jams become routine). A study done by the World Resources Institute in 1996-1997 estimated that the economic penalty of traffic jams in large cities can exceed hundreds of millions of dollars a year. Not to be left unsaid, traffic jams are also linked to increased road rage and overall agitation/aggression/hypertension in societies (certainly a problem I have noticed become exacerbated in Karachi over the past few years).

There are many reasons given for traffic jams in pakistan. Some can be considered plausible for a city that is overpopulated and has been mismanaged throughout its growth, but some other reasons are just plain ridiculous. Road constructions, vendor encroachments, unlawful parking especially outside school zones, frequent and illegal bus stops, sewage spills, lack of rain water drainage, security for VIPs, and a general lack of civic sense in the driving population are reasons that can be easily identified by any of us who have had the pleasure of being stuck in a traffic jam.

Question then remains what are the authorities doing about it, and what should be done? Owais has already written on the problem of underpasses versus flyovers. News clippings in pakistan now talk about planned construction of high speed corridors for city buses, and revamping of the local rail system for commuting (the plans have their critics, some quite justified given prior experiences with such schemes).

Many countries now have high occupancy lanes to encourage car pooling, and some countries (even China) have already started deploying intelligent traffic alert systems on traffic jam in rainroads so drivers can take detours when traffic starts to build up. Pakistan has experimented with bridges for pedestrian crossing on some major streets, but that has seen limited success in a population that does not seem to want to climb a few steps when they can just run across the street.

This may sound too simple to some but I also believe that promotion of more considerate driving behaviour (such as preventing tailgating, frequent lane changes, and turning without signals) can also help tremendously. Last but not the least, there may be a role for infrastructure planners to consider how to prevent all kinds of traffic from hogging the roads at the same time, even during rush hours. How many times have we gone through a major traffic jam to realize that a slow moving donkey cart, with tons of construction steel loaded on it, was the root cause of the problem?

Can we stop bicycles, donkey carts, etc. from entering the main roads and highways, please? As for the VIPs, give them the same treatment as the donkey carts. No need for them to hog the main highways.

9 responses to “Traffic jams: Not just a menace but also a loss”

  1. Musthak Ahmed says:

    I wanna be in Karachi City. Somebody told me that this City looks like Mumbai (India). Pls send more picture of Karachi City on my email.


    Musthak Ahmed
    Bangalore (India)

  2. qurratulain says:

    I am Qurrat ul Ain and am living in Liaquatabad, karachi and I feel the huge trouble about the Karachi Traffic and my family some disturb about this situation. we are 2 sister and 5 brother. My father businessman.

  3. qurratulain says:

    AoA Everyone onboard,

    First of all the blog is really a very good one, this type of intellectual platforms ar needed badly now a days.

    Secondly, i’m a karachite living here. The supreme development, besides other developments which i observed in the city, is the develpoment of ‘road traffic’. Well in my opinion the only thing we have been lacking since the very first day is planning. cars are being sold at zero % markup, and variety of car financing schemes are being used by financial institutions, with out any planning and coordination with government. If soo many cars are being brought on roads the proper road network should also be dveloped. Secondly the preference should be given to public transport. other factors also contribute in this case but i think the main problem is “Massive vehicles without planning”.



  4. Eidee Man says:

    Hi, no sane person would argue that the traffic situation in Karachi is good. Our people routinely break rules, etc etc.

    BUT, living in the US, I’ve noticed that whenever a road closing or some incident occurs, a lot of people go really crazy. They start overtaking each other, driving on patches of dirt, even grass in some cases. That suggests to me that people are bound to act crazy when the conditions are bad. If Karachi was administered properly, our traffic would actually be pretty sane.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *