Adil Najam
This rather striking picture, taken by Associated Press in Peshawar Pakistan is remarkable just for it captivating composition. But I have no doubt that our readers will not disappoint in making more of this than probably needs to be made!
39 comments posted
Have Your Say (Bol, magar piyar say)
Please respect the ATP Comment Policy.
Keep comments on topic; no personal attacks; don't submit indecent, inflammatory, slanderous, uncivil or irrelevant comments; flamers and trolls are not welcome; inappropriate comments will be removed or edited.
If you won't say it to someone's face, then don't say it here!
Readers who want to use a URL should please use the TINY URL program.
Thanks, and keep the comments coming!
You can visit ATP on your Mobile Phone. Here's how!
Search Engine Optimization (SEO) - search engine optimization and advertising specialist.
The real battle is one of identity. The battle continues. As you guys say we are a divided society.
Tina: thanks for explaining - makes sense to me.
Taban.Khamosh: The importation of the Arabic influence in the guise of Islamization is in fact the second phase of the rebellion of the natives against the state …
Don’t underestimate the “we are not India” roots. Better to be associated with the pure in Arabia - even if they have trouble reading, and believe we’re an inferior race - than to be identified with the money-grabbing, “cunning” Hindu bania. May not be as important now - but the formative years were a determined effort to make sure Lahore felt different from Delhi and that you were not in Lucknow or Meerut any more. As one commentator put it, life went “right to left”.
I posted some pictures of Valentine’s Day in Islamabad on my website Pakistan Journal. You can check them at http://pakistanjournal.com
Don’t forget we have to ban GREEN also as that is the color of Christmas….
I think our beloved Saudis got it right - we should ban anything that is red on Valentines day. Paint over all the Red Crescent signs - rename the Red Sea …
then ban anything orange for Halloween… ban pink on Mothers Day, blue on Father’s day
And also, to constantly say that non-Arabs have nothing to contribute to Islamic thought, and have never contributed anything that is worthwhile or correct (unless Arabs agree with it), is to say in effect that Islam is so tied into Arabic identity as to be a religion only for Arabs. This is the opposite of what most Muslims believe Islam teaches.
I’m not sure if it’s the active export on the part of the decrepit Arab cultures or the vacuum inside our own cultural landscape that is sucking all the gunk in.
The trojan horse of course is the one true way or “the Islamic way”, and the payload is every idiocy, ritual and superficialiaty associated with the “golden days of empire”. But the reasons of this change are still connected to the homicidal economic & culture wars being waged inside Pakistan amongst the various interest groups. (Natives vs. the Self Imposed Saahibs)
The vacuum of course has been left in the wake of the silly culture war that was fought for the supremacy of Urdu/Nazria-Pakistan and the stalemate and the unwritten truce that has followed after the sinking of that particular boat ( in the Bay of Bengal) has basically allowed the Arabic/Islamic influence to come in. Buy why Arabic influence? Why doesthe vacuum prefer the Arabic influence over Western or Iranian influence? (or even Indian for that matter?) I think it is because the outward Arabization gives itself legitimacy through being subconsciously being equated to Islam itself. (and everyone knows keh “Pakistan kaa matlab kia” hai!)
IMO, The importation of the Arabic influence in the guise of Islamization is in fact the second phase of the rebellion of the natives against the state and therefore the dominant and coercive cultural apparatus that vied to maintain control of resources and levers of power (through cultural dominance) over the natives. Interest group politics packaged in a sacred box colored white and green with a big ole chaaNd-sitaara sploched all over it.
Any display of local identities can be brutally attacked and crushed by the coercive organs of the state, but what are you going to do when the same drive is exhibited through another even more “sacred” identity. The local identities, instead of dying at the hands of the center, have killed (negated?) themselves (in part) and re-constituted the struggle against the “center” (the invisible hand, the establishment, the language executioners etc.) using a newer more violent “Islamic” narrative.
The war is still the same, but it is being fought in new garb, under seemingly different pretexts and apparently unrelated contexts. While in fact it is still about economic interests, but everyone involved has figured out that the old ways of control aren’t working. However, the same group holds the coercive powers of the state, therefore the need to change to a newer more violent “Islamic” (outwardly Arabized) tint to the struggle (of the disadvantaged natives.)
The ethnic and linguistic makeup of the suicide bombers and the various “Lashkar-e-X” are clues to that particular dynamic.
At least that’s what I think right now.