Adil Najam
From reading the comments on our last Photo Quiz, probably not.
It was a trick question, and I do not think I would have gotten it right either; even though this is a city that I am mightily fond of.
I guess I am being a tease (‘teaser’ in Pinglish, but also in English). Yes, Owais Mughal did get it right and a number of other folks did consider it but were not fully sure.
The city is Quetta.
I have never actually lived in Quetta but have visited often, including a number of recent work related trips. I am particularly fond of this city and its people; and, of course, its food.
It has a rich, and sometimes tragic (earthquakes) history, and is a place that is used to ‘living on the edge’ — literally and metaphorically. More on that some other time. For now, I do want to say something about the four photographs here. All, including the original posted yesterday, are by cageitfallsinto, whose portfolio at Flickr has a wonderful collection from around the world, including Pakistan.
The original phtograph is taken from Koh-e-Murdar, looking down on the night lights of Quetta. I believe (from my www map research!) that the lights on the bottom left are Mariabad, the dark spot after that are the mountains continuing, beyond that the lights on the top-left are from Quetta city and Sariyab Road area, on the right are Gulistan Town, Alamdar Road, Toghi Road, Hajiabad, and back into the city area. I may be wrong, if so, please do tell us more.
As I said, this was a trick question. The obvious answer would have been Islamabad from Daman-i-Koh or from Pir Sohawa. I think, the first would leave you with the problem of the missing Faisal Mosque (on the right) and both would have the challenge of why lights from Rawalpindi are not also visible into the horizon and the absence of a grid-like structure of lights. For this to be Karachi, as a number of people pointed out, you would have to explain the mountains. Lahore, someone said, the smog. Although that may be a slight over-statement.
To the best of my knowledge, this picture was not ‘photoshopped’. If that is correct, then the ‘Quetta-ness’ of this picture comes not from the lights (that really could have been any mid-sized city). The ‘Quetta-ness’ comes from what is around the lights. The silent darkness. Being the valley town ‘cupped’ amidst mountains, Quetta has a special feel to it; which, once you know this is Quetta, seeps through. Most other cities trickle away into suburbia and then villages (to be fair, that sense may not be captured in a picture; but you cannot escape it on the ground). Quetta is truly a frontier town. Its majesty really does loom out of a surrounding that remains mostly uninhabited; more so that any other major town in Pakistan.
Anyhow, those are my thoughts. As I said, this was not an easy one to guess… but we had fun anyhow in trying to!
Finally, a few words about the other three pictures here. Which, hopefully, also help shake our stereotypes about Quetta. First, on the top of the post, the picture of the lone street light only highlights that darkness can hide many things and not every point of light is created equal. The beauty of the picture taken from afar should not make us oblivious of the real issues and challenges up close. The two other pictures are of houses tucked into the face of the mountain and of the hot water pools at Pir Ghaib. Both are places worth going to. Buit Owais will soon be telling us more about that!
Aziz sb, very appropriate sheyr, as always.
I am so glad you pick up on this point, which I was trying to make by putting that picture of the lone and lonesome streetlight next to the beautiful picture next to it.
It does bother me now, that growing up I was, in so many ways, more aware of the larger world than of the country I was living in. I fear that we have been producing urban generations who find it easier to fit in and feel comfortable in London, England than in Landikotal, NWFP; or in Birmingham, Alabama more than in Baluchistan, Pakistan. This is by no means just a Pakistani phenomenon. It is clearly bigger. The ‘global citizen’ may be global but, because of exactly that reason, can be very lonely too. Of course, the very fact that globalization connects some people and some locations also means that it can enhance the disconnections and marginalization of others. The current crises in Baluchistan and Quetta are a case in point. That neglect does not even make news (not even on ATP; well, not yet… but we will!); spitting on a cricket ball does!
But, I digress…. as you know from previous posts, I do think these connections are important.
The second thought which came in my my after Pir Sohawa (Islamabad) was Abbotabad. One can find a similar view of Abbotabad on the way to Thandiani. Though I had a chance to go to Quetta several times but could not get the oppurtunity to see it from Koh-e-Murdar at night.
It was an interesting quiz!
Unfortunately, Balochistan is going through hard times these days, I hope the things will get better as this area has great potential in its natural resources, agriculture and livestock.
Adil,
It’s interesting to see that no one — almost no one — thought of Quetta when guessing the city in this picture. This shows that when we, including myself, think of Pakistan we mostly think of Karachi, Lahore, Islamabad (and, of course, Rawalpindi) and sometime Peshwar but rarely of Quetta or Balochistan. Balochistan in our minds is a vast emptiness, bereft of people and their problems, just like the vast darkness that surrounds the small concentration of lights in the picture.
You have said something very important in the post that ” The beauty of the picture taken from afar should not make us oblivious of the real issues and challenges up close.” And Faiz (it is always Faiz who comes to our help when we can’t find words) expressed the same sentiment in his poem, “yahaN say sheh ko daikhoâ€
eteraz, I am a Essakhelvi fan but had not heard that one before…. I just did….. the audio is available on the internet here:
http://www.muziq.net/showpage.php?page=album.php?s how=showall&artistid=63&albid=all&limit=28
yaar adil
im looking for zikar jab chirr gaya uun ki angraii ka by ataullah khan eesa khailvi
can u upload it?