Adil Najam
In what is clearly a historic development, the Prime Minister of Pakistan Syed Yousuf Raza Gillani addressed the nation to announce the reinstatement of Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammad Chaudhry. The address, which was supposed to be at 2AM Pakistan Time, was late by many hours but the subtext was true to the rumors that had been circulating in Pakistan all day:
Here is the full text of the Prime Minister’s speech:
My dear countrymen Assalam-o-Alaikum,
I am speaking to you at a time when our country is standing at a critical moment. No country can make progress without political tolerance and the PPP and lawyers have been together in struggle for upholding democracy in Pakistan. Shaheed Mohtrama Benazir Bhutto actively participated in the struggle of restoration of judiciary was launched by lawyers. Benazir Bhutto wanted free judiciary and supremacy of the constitution.
The lawyers’ movement for restoring of judges was their democratic right. The PPP was shoulder to shoulder with the lawyers in the cause for the independent judiciary.
The slain PPP leader Benazir Bhutto also wanted to reinstate the deposed chief justice.
I have taken all his coalition partners and the President into confidence about the reinstatement of the deposed chief justice once the current chief justice retires on March 21.
The deposed chief justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry will assume charges on March 21.
Benazir Bhutto wanted free judiciary and supremacy of the constitution.
I order all the provincial government to abolish Section 144 at once.
After consultations with all political forces of the country and President Asif Ali Zardari, we have decided to restore all deposed judges including Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry as Chief Justice of Pakistan who will assume charge on March 21. The current Chief Justice Abdul Hameed Dogar retires on March 21. I urge all the political forces and lawyers to work for the solidarity and welfare of the country.
Pakistan Paindabad.
Just over two years after he was first unceremoniously removed by Gen. Pervaiz Musharraf, and having once been restored by the Supreme Court, Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammad Chaudhry has now been ‘restored’ yet again as the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Pakistan. The road from there has been tumultuous. The movement that gathered around him was always bigger than the CJ and it was bigger than those around him. The vindication today is not simply of Chief Justice Chaudhry, it is a vindication of Pakistan’s civil society.
ATP has covered the ups and down of this story. For some reason one has a sense that this story is not over yet. We have celebrated a reinstatement once before too. And from the PM’s speech it is not clear at all what the terms of the decision really are. But right now one wishes simply to bask in the joyousness of the moment, in the vindication of justice, in the goodness of the news. There is much analysis that is needed, but let us leave that for just a little later.
Aitezaz Ahsan has expressed the hope that Justice Chaudhry will not hear any petition against the NRO in the supreme court.
One hope that Mian sahib agrees also.
Welcome to the ‘independent’ judiciary.
Restoration of a judge may diffuse the situation for a while however fact remains that corrupt politicians will continue to rip the country by all means. Mr Zardari is a feudal lord he knows well where to place which servant. He will be manouvered to end up as a total failure. One can clearly see that his restoration and relief to common Pakistani person has no connection. He is no masiah which these poor people think of him. I can see same cheer leaders will be out protesting again.
Restoration of a judge may diffuse the situation for a while however fact remains that corrupt politicians will continue to rip the country by all means. Mr Zardari is a feudal lord he knows well where to place which servant. He will be manouvered to end up as a total failure. One can clearly see that his restoration and relief to common Pakistani person has no connection. He is no masiah which these poor people think of him. I can see same cheer leaders will be out protesting again.
” Hum Zinda Quam Hain Painda Quam Hain
Hum sab ki hai Pehchan, Hum sab ka Pakistan
Pakistan Pakistan Pakistan
Hum sab ka Pakistan ”
“We are an alive Nation — We are a Resilient Nation”
This was a good day for Pak, as far as correcting the illigal acts of Army dictator Musharraf.
It can set a healthy precedent and future dictators ( Military or civilian ) may think twice before committing such acts.
Now the groups that had assembled under the ‘Justice banner’ - have their own agendas and include obscrutinist elements who would dump the chief justice in garbage dump if he ventured in Swat.
How this all eventually plays out, will remain to be seen.
The humiliating retreat by the deeply unpopular President of Pakistan, Mr. Asif Ali Zardari, on the question of restoring Chief Justice Iftikhar Chaudhry is reminiscent of a similar debacle by his equally unpopular predecessor, former President Musharraf, in 2007. Both leaders seriously miscalculated the public outrage against their actions. In addition to mass protests on the streets, both men had to face tremendous pressures by foreign powers, including Americans and Saudis, as well as strong private rebuke by the ultimate arbiters of power in Pakistani military. As the events unfold further, it seems that Mr. Zardari has been so badly weakened that he will be forced to resign in not too distant a future. Until that happens, Pakistan will continue to face significant instability and continuing and serious security threats from within and outside.
Sufi Muhammad has said that “Nizam-e-Adl” is now in force and does not require the President’s signature. He has told Judges to stay away from the courts which will now be run by Qazis appointed by him! Sounds familiar? Think… Nov 3, 2007. Are we going to have another Long March? Or, are these just a bunch of backward Pathans in the mountains… who cares!??
Qazi Hussain Ahmed said that “we had waited 61 years for ‘Nizam-e-Adl’ to finally be established in Pakistan”. He said this while celebrating with the lawyers, civil society and political workers (i.e. religious fascists of all ilk (just check the flags and banners being waved), and their appeasers the TI and PML(N)) this morning. This from the leader of a party that opposed Jinnah. Has Jinnah really won? Have we really done anything to ensure that Jinnah’s vision as expressed by him on 11th August 1947 is any closer to becoming a reality?
Have we forgotten how these guys treat Asma Jehangir, Tahira Abdullah and will do Ghazala Minallah? Akhtar Hameed Khan? Imran Khan and even Nawaz Sharif are gravely mistaken if they think the likes of Sufi Muhammad will be happy to stay ‘junior partners’. They have the guns, the hate, the nihilism and the will.
The Taliban in Swat will not be disarmed, according to the deal. They will merely ‘lay down’ their arms.. but keep them close at hand. That is what allows Sufi Muhammad to declare the President of Pakistan’s signature irrelevant. This is what we have capitulated to.
This cannot be called the Swatis’ free choice. How can you make a free choice when the Taliban hold a gun to your head and the state and it’s army have clearly abdicated all legal and moral repsonsibility and abandoned you!
Now it’d be free choice if Sharia were imposed in Zaman Park, or Raiwind farms/Model Town H block, or Defence Housing Society, or E7. Do that, and I’ll have more respect for these guys’ motives, even if none for their views. Dwellers of Mansura at least are not dishonest.. respectably determined, dangerous fascists.
How many in the media speak up against this? How many condone it? How many accept it as invetibale? We have hailed a largely blinkered media and its virtual black out of the ‘other’ opinion, for its almost blanket support of CJ Chaudhry. Now will we take control and show the media that we will not be led by it? A free media is a great and precious thing. Do we have the capability and will to now force this free media to start becoming more objective… and professional?
If we think that the country can go forward while at the same time ignoring the girls of Swat being pushed back to the dark ages.. we are very gravely mistaken. Are those girls not Pakistani? Are they not human?
It is a good day for the people of Pakistan. This is not about the Chief Justice or Nawaz Sharif and we shoudl always remember not to make it about them. This was about Pakistanis saying “enough is enough” and showing politicial persistence to get institutions right.
Bad day for enemies of Pakistan who are all sad today.
PAKISTAN ZINDABAD!