Indus Day and Pakistan’s Depleting Water Resources

Posted on January 28, 2010
Filed Under >Owais Mughal, Disasters, Environment
Total Views: 66294


Owais Mughal

Pakistan is in drought. Rivers are flowing with 30% less water than what they normally do in January. For a country whose econnomy depends on agriculture and irrigation water, drought couldn’t have come at a worst time.

The photo above shows dry bed of river Indus on March 14, 2009 downstream of Kotri barrage at Jamshoro. Indus by the way is supposed to collect water from all major rivers of Pakistan. This photo shows the reality of Pakistan’s supposedly all-year flowing river.

An excerpt from today’s Dawn news reads:

The Pakistan Meteorological Department has said that the country had already crossed two stages of drought, meteorological and hydrological drought, and was now entering the emerging agricultural drought stages, resulting in crop failures in arid areas and drought conditions in irrigated plains.

Following is another photo of dry bed of Indus downstream of Hyderabad in November 2009.

Officials of the Indus River System Authority (IRSA) which manages water resources have said on Jan 25, 2010 that the rate of water flow in country’s four major rivers had fallen from 47,000 cubic feet per second last year to 37,000 cubic feet per second this year.

The total water stored in the Tarbela and Mangla reservoirs dropped by 34 percent over the year — down from nearly 2.26 million acre-feet in January 2009 to nearly 1.5 million acre-feet in January 2010. According to a Jan 16, 2010 news item water level in Tarbela reservoir was 131 feet below maximum and in Mangla it was 128 feet below maximum.

As water resources deplete, the general fear is that Pakistan’s political and regional conflicts will emerge stronger. While the problem is not confined to any one province but when water resources get stressed the strain shows in the form of allegations and polarization of people into groups. Regional tonga parties which otherwise don’t get any support can suddenly exploit thousands to support their slogans of ‘mazloomiat’ (being exploited).

Therefore it was not very surprising to see the unanimous support ‘Indus River Day’ received in Sindh province on Jan 24, 2009. It was not covered widely by the National Press but few photographs that I’ve seen from the event showed the passion with which people in Sindh consider this to be an issue which is very close to them.

The photo to the left above shows traffic jam on Khairpur-Larkana bridge on River Indus as large number of people throng to the river banks to mark the ‘Indus Day’

The photo to the right shows an old timer praying at the banks of Indus in Larkana on the occasion of Indus River day.

While regional parties of Sindh made it a point to bring their supporters in large numbers to the banks of Indus and throw tonnes of rose petals into the river, one of the larger political parties of the country – which does business at National level – also offered ‘namaz-e-istasqa’ (prayer for rains) in their Karachi offices.

The photo to the left shows rose petals being thrown into Indus waters as a gesture of thanks and prayers to the river water which supports life and economy of many here.

I believe it is indeed a national problem which needs a national solution.

For the past many years, somebody keeps coming up with an idea of melting glaciers to fill up our dams. This idea appears in National Press every now and then. Does it hold any serious merit? To me it seems like killing the goose that lays golden eggs to get all the eggs now. Bad idea. For a qucik reward we shouldn’t mess with the nature more than we already have. I am sure these glaciers don’t form overnight or every year. They have been in Pakistan probably since the last ice age.

The photo above shows dry spill ways of Rawal Dam on last sunday (Jan 24, 2010). The water has gone down below dead level here.

Whether making one large Kalabagh dam is the solution, I don’t know for sure. I’ll let our readers judge and comment on the merits of larger versus smaller dams. I do tend to think that conservation at regional levels by small dams is better. They will have smaller environmental impact. While drought cannot be tamed, its effects can be reduced by recycling of domestic water and channelled (or even covered) water ways with concrete lining. ‘magar is meiN parti hai mehnat ziyaada’. Where will the funds come from for such infrastructure improvement? Do we have a collective insight to channel funds towards water conservation. These days all the countries want to donate something to Pakistan – may be its time to ask them and our own ashaab-e-ikhtiaar (decision makers) to invest in Pakistan’s Water Resources for the stability of the country and the region.

I want to end this post with following astonishing photo where people are seen walking at leisure on dry Indus bed at Jamshoro on June 29, 2009.

Photo Credits: Nadeem Akhtar, Akram Ali and Saeed-ul-Mulk at APP

10 Comments on “Indus Day and Pakistan’s Depleting Water Resources”

  1. DARWEESH says:
    January 28th, 2010 6:15 am

    We cant get more water in our rivers by throwing rose petals in rivers and performing some rituals like dancing and singing.
    Practical steps need to be taken at official level by ruling political parties. Unfortunately their leaders have lost all directions except fighting to save their Kursian .Kursi khape is their slogan and this Indus Day a gimic to distract hungry teeming millions

  2. Farigh says:
    January 28th, 2010 7:22 am

    Thats the reality on ground and I wonder people still insist on making Kalabagh dam

  3. Taimur Khan says:
    January 28th, 2010 10:08 am

    Very concerning situation for us. No doubt, water is a life line for us. But, our government seems less concerned about the situation, as apparently, they don’t have any solution to this right now.
    We have to review Indus Water treaty as early as possible and get this water grabbing situation from India resolved with the help of International community and Muslim world support.
    Or otherwise, whether you like it or not, we are going to have a regional war sooner or later. And, I think the establishment on the other side of the border is also forcing the situation in that way, as to make us be the first ones to attack them.

  4. Aziz says:
    January 28th, 2010 11:57 am

    Oh my god. I remember travelling on Kotri barrage at Jamshoro and the water was atleast half way to those columns shown in the picture. But again, that was sometime in 1990. I have read about water issues in Pakistan but my own research shows that there should be no water issues in this country. It is the neglect of government that is finally showing up in the way of water shortage. You say drought…what drought? We have one of the world’s largest snow capped mountains. If the melting water can be stored properly, we should not have to worry and pray for rain every year. The issue goes back to Gen. Zia-ul-Haq’s regime where he failed to invest in infrastructure and build proper dams.

    As far as Kalabagh dam is concerned, I personally think that it was a good idea. We needed something to store water. However, I agree with Owais that smaller dams at the local level would be more beneficial. It is time that the provincial government take charge and build their own dams, ofcourse with considerations to all provinces.

    Sindh kept fighting Kalabagh Dam. They failed to see how much water is being dumped into Arabian Sea. A small dam to collect that water would have gone a long way to stabilize Sindh’s water supply. Yes yes, I know that Sindh needed fresh water dumped into the sea to neutralize salt blah blah blah but those things can but put into conditions of building the dam. This is all political. Building a dam at the bottom of the Indus River will not bring as much press to the political parties as it would to oppose some dam being build up north.

    In 1960s Pakistan gave up the control of 3 major rivers to India in return of funding a Kalabagh type dam. However, internal conflicts have prevented successive governments from building these dams. Our leaders have done stupid things and then stupider things to cover up those stupid things. This is one such example.

    I suggest the government do the following as soon as possible.

    1. Create emergency funds to build small dams along the Indus to store water.
    2. Build water recycling plants all over the country to collect water from drains, clean it and put it back in the main water supply channel
    3. As someone else suggested, work with India to resolve water ownership issues.

    OR our political leaders should just do what they are supposed to do and we won’t see these issues :)

  5. Owais Mughal says:
    January 28th, 2010 12:01 pm

    Aziz. appreciate your comment.

  6. January 28th, 2010 10:55 pm

    Some comments from the ATP Facebook Page:

    - “Its an alarming situation. dont understand wat concerned authorities are doin.”
    - “authorities are simply chatting, n doing nothing, n God knows what these ppl going to do to this beloved soil”
    - ” India doesnt need to wage another war against us they are using the most cost effective and beneficial method to destroy us i.e. they are tapping away all our water”
    - “Global warming has resulted in rapidly melting glaciers, we have to think wisely about constructing dams to store water during summer.Indians have to release water during heavy rains in summer other wise they will get drowned.”

  7. Sohail says:
    January 29th, 2010 12:28 am

    The only thing we can do is to resolve all our differences with India or they will starve us all to death. We obviously cannot attack them or fight a war, they are too strong and the entire world will stand with them. We must offer them an end to all hostility. Us harping about the Kashmir issue will not work. It has not for 60 years and has only brought us the terrorist tag world wide. It is time for us to put the interests of 170 million Pakistanis before 5 million Kashmiris. We must offer the Indians a grand bargain – we accept status quo in Kashmir and accept LoC as the border and hand over to them all LeT leaders. In return, they commit to providing us water from all 5 indus rivers and commit to never using force against us and the global community ensures that they will stand by this.

  8. Hira Mir says:
    January 29th, 2010 6:04 am

    @darwesh. Very well said. Just to throw in a figure Pakistan received 1.4 billion rupees to improve the ability of Tarbela dam but God knows where that money went!! If there was transparency in the public institutions one could know surely!!

  9. Owais Mughal says:
    January 29th, 2010 11:43 am

    The 1991 Water Accord called for 10 million acres feet (MAF) water flow down stream of Kotri per annum. This accord has recently been renewed (last month). I am not sure what is the latest MAF number required to be released downstream of Kotri. am looking for it.

  10. Owais Mughal says:
    January 29th, 2010 11:44 am

    Rubina Jabbar’s article on Indus delta water needs. Read here

Have Your Say (Bol, magar piyar say)