Give me 85 Seconds, Please.

Posted on August 23, 2009
Filed Under >Adil Najam, People, Poetry
22 Comments
Total Views: 40180

Adil Najam

Dear readers, please give me just 85 seconds of your time.

Take a deep breath, and then take a listen to the audio recording below. It will take all of 1 minute and 25 seconds.

[Audio:http://www.kidvai.com/windmills/Media/Latee fah.mp3]

And, then, if you can give me just 30 seconds more, take a deep breath and think about what you have heard.

If you wish to share that thought with other readers, we will be delighted. But even if you don’t, do please think.

The recording comes to us via Zakintosh’s wonderful blog, Windmills of My Mind. We have, of course, written about Zaheer Alam Kidvai before and also carried some wonderful material from his blog, especially his Yaadayn (here and here). The recording was in a post about Independence Day, and this is how he set it up:

From Leaders to Facebookers, from the Steeple to Tweeple, everyone is still asking others to do something for Pakistan, even if it is just to superficially ‘go green’ by changing your display picture.

In 1949, when I was almost 9 and Pakistan had just turned 2, Abi (my father, Azhar Kidvai) wrote a poem that he read out on at a small mushaaerah celebrating Independence Day. While the rest of the poem was simple and understable enough at that age, too, it was the brief section of it that contained an anecdote I found very amusing and read it often enough to have it permanently etched in mind. Listen to me reciting it for my daughter, Ragni, a few years ago.

This is one of the most heart moving and pertinent things I have heard for a long time. It reminded me of one of my favorite sheyr (itself inspired by the famous JFK line):

jissay bhi daikhiaye gilla,
watan say yeh nahiN milla,
watan say woh nahiN milla.

Koee nahiN jo yeh kahay,
watan ko meiN nay kiya diya,
watan ko tumm nay kiya diya.

I think Kidvai sahib’s poem is so much more powerful; in its simplicity and its poignancy. It puts so many things into perspective, including some of the comments and naaras we get from our readers here, and even more on our Facebook page.

Shameless we might be – we too ask people to go green, and who did the most good or most harm to the country. But ultimately, the question is “watan ko meiN nay kiya diya, watan ko tumm nay kiya diya.”

My late grandmother was a very wise woman (all grandmothers are). She used to say that when you point one finger at someone else, at least three point right back at you. Wise words that we should all pay heed to. Just as we pay heed to the words of Kidvai sahib’s father.

22 responses to “Give me 85 Seconds, Please.”

  1. Jalal HB says:

    Fantastic find and thanks for sharing. I wish such literature ever finds its practical manifestation

  2. Daktar says:

    Very nice post. Excellent recording (thank you Mr. Kidvai) and excellent writeup (thank you Mr. Najam).

    One of the many things I like about this website is that its attitude has always been “these are our problems and lets solve them ourselves rather than finding others (usually India, US, Israel, etc.) to blame.” Like you id on teh IDP fundraising you did. I appreciated that you asked others to chip in but did even more yourself. that is the spirit, what can I do to solve the problem rather than pointing fingers at others.

  3. Raheel says:

    Beautiful!

    Not only about our homeland, but in every prospect of our lives, we have lost positivity in the hands of selfishness.

    Alhamdolillah, we are blessed.

  4. Dr. Qureshi says:

    Adil, is this the same Zaheer Kidwai who did the Faiz Ahmad Faiz CD some years ago. I also heard he did something on art but have never been able to get my hand on it. I wish he had done more of those. I still have by Faiz CD and prize it.

  5. Watan Aziz says:

    Great pearl of wisdom.

    But is it universal in its application?

    What if they took my ghara away? What if they did not allow me to make my own ghara? Or used kiln for their own ghara and told me to sun bake my own? What if they used finest clay to make their ghara and told me to mix clay with sand?

    Should we have asked Bengalis about their ghara?

    Should a rape victim not point finger? Muktharn Mai?

    Should Pastor Yousaf not say make the white red after Gojra?

    Should people who use water that we would not use in our toilets ask, where is this “access” to safe drinking water for 90 of us?

    These are moral dilemmas. Hard to answer. Early bird catches the worm; except the worm did have bad luck. Rolling stone gathers no moss but then harkat mein barkat.

    Is Asimov right when he says

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*