Being Woman in Pakistan

Posted on May 26, 2007
Filed Under >Aisha Sarwari, Society, Women
172 Comments
Total Views: 186047

Guest Post by Aisha Sarwari

“This is why I am not in favor of working women.” Said the Colonel and security in-charge of one of Lahore’s largest office blocks. “Excuse me?” I said.

Before I could unleash my monologue on the tirade of women’s mobility, I am interrupted by the drama unfolding in the Colonel’s office where two security guards, a police man, a fellow plaza worker and the culprit who “teased” me shift uncomfortably in their chairs.

A few moments ago, I was walking up the stairs from the parking lot, late for a board meeting, shoving my car keys in my ancient purse, while two men who appeared to have camaraderie with each other were coming down. As they passed me, the uglier guy with glasses greeted me with strange familiarity and boldness.

I was used to the whistling, the smirks, the humming of latest Bollywood songs or even a religious proclamation of how great God is. But this sort of thing, however, had me stop and take notice. I asked for a clarification from him, and he went on to make generally trivial chit-chat about his friend giving me a call later.

Understanding full well that chauvinists thrive on women’s passivity, I learned to give in to my indignity and forgo the fight of telling random men off. Sometimes even when I want to fight back, their timing is too perfect and their precision that of a seasoned actor on Broadaway. Before I can feel the stab of inferiority and their power to communicate a stark message, they are gone, under the folds of a society that is so sickly South Asian. Everyday it is a battle, but I trivialize the over-sexualization of a partially segregated society whose religion rests on a mother/whore dichotomy. It’s nothing, I say, not worth it. But the truth is its very bloody and it wounds me each time and it leaves its mark every time it happens.

So this time, I fought back. I called for two guards who were directing traffic in the underground basement. New at their job, they refused to budge because they didn’t have “orders” to move from the spot that both of them were designated on to stand. I couldn’t believe it. This was no time for bureaucracy. Exasperated, but still somewhat in control, I let the guys flea, but I went to give the wannabe pedestal guards a piece of my mind. I could hear myself becoming a whiny powerless nagging woman. I hated it, but what could I do? I had to ask them why the hell they didn’t come when I called them, a total idiot just got away.

By then enough men, old men, young men, men with family values, men who believe women need protection and those who just wanted to watch a show from the other side had gathered to catch the “honor-less” folk. They asked me to identify the person. I found myself increasingly being part of a large Victorian drama — Damsels in Distress. I hated this too.

So due to cleaver James Bond action the men caught one of the guys who tried to get away. There was some motorbike skidding involved. Eventually the guy removes his helmet. I ask him if he was the person whose friend was attempting to be entertaining. He said yes and I proceeded to ask him why he was laughing about it and didn’t tell his friend to take a break. At which he became a local Punjabi Sultan Rahi and stopped short of beating his baboon chest, mouth foaming action and all. He asked me who the hell I was to tell him anything, that I should shut up and know my place. I went ahead and told him to talk in English after he learned the language, and also that I was now going to make him regret what he just did.

Thanks to his daring proximity the thought of slapping him did come to mind, but why should I lie, I was scared of him. Taken by the nerve to be so aggressive toward me in front of a crowd of armed guards, I didn’t want to test which of the genders has a knack for violence, it was a well discovered territory for all women.

I took a deep breath and called for Mr. Pathan, the chief security guard who in the true sense of the word was a guard. He arrived on the scene with his 3 inch by 6 inch mustache folded towards the edges in a circle loop. Once he arrived, he grabbed the lad with his neck asked the rest of his supervisors to take care of the bike while he walked briskly toward the Colonel’s office, asked the girl to follow. Once he discovered the girl was me (He thinks I am Syed), he broke into a fit of ass-whopping of the lad, where he asserted who exactly possessed the lion’s mane and where he was in the food chain. This was his territory and there was some order here. The kicking, shoving and slaps continued two floors up via the car slopes and into the office.

I greeted the colonel who was kind enough to keep a reserved parking space for me for the past few months, “because I was a woman” after a couple of vandalism incidents with my car. We sat down and I narrated what happened. The fellow plaza worker talked about what he saw. When I gave my version, I knew I could never explain the concept of “perceived threat” and how much that can terrify a person. It is the unsaid rule that if you dare to report, or take action it’ll be marked as a protest against the status quo and there will be retaliation, and the last word won’t be yours.

The Colonel said that it is hard for these guys to differentiate between the “type” of women they see. Some women hold men’s hand in the parking lot. What he meant to say was, this was a simple case of miscalculation. You lady, are a married woman, with kids, I know your boss, your husband and so via the men associated with you, you deserve respect and I’ll punish these men accordingly.

Already the guy, thanks to Mr. Pathan’s mighty blows was a lamb, apologizing profusely after he heard the police man suggest jail, where he’d eventually call in his friend and settle the score. I asked him to define what he was sorry for, and it was quiet clear he was sorry about landing in the crap that he found himself in, not for the harm caused to me. The fellow plaza office worker, though harsh with the guy, was ultimately asking me to forgive and let him go. Men, after all have to protect other men, it was harmless, understandably a misjudgment that should not get you in so much trouble for. You can get into trouble for theft, murder and burglary but this is just a woman.

The Colonel asked me. What do you want to do?

Men oppress women because that’s how it is. Its more natural for a woman to clean shoes apparently than it is for a man, that is in women’s nature, the cooking, cleaning and the menial tasks the surround child rearing, as well as the overwhelmingly huge ones that need emotional strength of an elephant, business intelligence of a working woman and those that require spiritual stability and nurturing forgiveness. All this time, no one asked us what we want to do.

Colonel Saab, I want him and his friend to know, that sometimes you can pick on the wrong woman, a pissed off one. Can you do that please? I asked him.

He placed his cigar on the ashtray and sighed.

Artwork by Abro.

172 responses to “Being Woman in Pakistan”

  1. kronstadter says:

    why r the new private tvs repeating the same mistake which the west n india has made i.e. crossing the limits of decency in the name of modernism and liberalism by showing all these dramas about pre-marial datings and sexual encounters! same goes for the music channels, the way they portray how cooooooool karachi n lahore is, simply by reason of guys n girls hanging-out together.

    Thanks for the lecture on social-conservative thought, but how exactly does it help explain the behavior of the two guys?

    may God save my kids from such modernism and ill-defined liberalism.

    whatelse can 1 expect from the new generation who watches these so called modern private channels, no wonder these kids now treat women as objects of amusement who have to be interfered with for the sake of it.

    Ah, I see. So basically you’re saying that women won’t be mis-treated if we don’t have “modernism” (as if that’s a bad thing) and “liberal” values.

    And you seem to assume that these guys wouldn’t have messed with the author if they hadn’t been exposed to contemporary TV content.

    Now, the first problem with your thesis is this: patriarchal oppression of women existed even BEFORE the TV was invented.

    The second problem with your (*ahem*) thesis is a place like Afghanistan. The Taliban banned the so-called “obscene” TV content which you’re referring to, but guess what?
    Women were still exploited and repressed.

    The solution to the problems of our society is not to insulate ourselves from the outside world, or sink into conservative backwardness. We need to embrace modernity.

    I agree with you that making women sex objects on TV is not desirable, its simply another form of patriarchy.
    True modernity means giving women education, employment and economic independence.

    There is no reason to fear women coming out of the home, like the Colonel in Aisha’s narrative does.
    In fact, we should be trying to encourage women to go out into the world and become productive citizens.

  2. Adnan Ahmad says:

    A well written post.

    Umar Khan has made a beautiful point in this line..

    “it is bcoz of this very rightly placed conservatism that the PATHAN security guard was the only (one) with the guts 2 fix the guy who was being problematic!”

  3. [quote comment=”48685″]
    however, i wonder why couldnt benazir in her twice elected regime do something about it?
    [/quote]

    Feminism in Pakistan is a very skewed concept where most of the ‘active’ feminists r talking about western feminist values, Benezir was one of them. Thats y she failed, first of all such a concept is too much to implement too soon and secondly, change has to be brought up keeping the cultural and religious aspects in mind.
    We need feminists like Assimah Asilmi for instance, or practicing muslim women like those in the US/UK for instance. powerful yet graceful.

    [quote]
    why r the new private tvs repeating the same mistake which the west n india has made i.e. crossing the limits of decency in the name of modernism and liberalism by showing all these dramas about pre-marial datings and sexual encounters! same goes for the music channels, the way they portray how cooooooool karachi n lahore is, simply by reason of guys n girls hanging-out together.

    may God save my kids from such modernism and ill-defined liberalism.
    [/quote]
    they all want burqa clad women to become meera/reema/sheema overnight :)

    [quote]
    whereas i am not in favour of taliban/iran style crackdown on channels, i am sceptical of such obscene and midplaced liberalism.
    [/quote]

    me too :)

    [quote]
    whereas the extreme conservatism of nwfp at times feels suffocating, atleast i am so much glad that we havent forgotten what our values are! though, women’s liberties r crushed, which is an unwelcomed consequene.

    it is bcoz of this very rightly placed conservatism that the PATHAN security guard was the only with the guts 2 fix the guy who was being problematic![/quote]

    I have a close friend from Hangu who once were sharing the experiences of life in this village when women were free to roam around and if a man was working in a farm for instance and women are passing by, he would simply move out of the way to allow them as much privacy as they need. Now, due to these immense pressure to put every woman on a matress billboard, things have become stricter in places like Hangu as well…

  4. ranasrule says:

    Iam ashmaed to call myself a Pakistani MAN when i hear of tales like this.

  5. kronstadter says:

    Utterly disgraceful behavior on the part of the two idiots.

    Having said that, we need to look at the roots of their disgusting behavior. It’s important to realize that patriarchy is not merely an idea in their head, or the product of their individual egos.
    Patriarchy is an institution, and as such, must be dismantled as an INSTITUTION. That would mean widespread social changes, and it would require nation-wide efforts aimed at providing women equality with men.

    We must respect the author of this piece for her courage in standing up to this disgusting behavior, but we must also realize that most Pakistani women are brought up in an environment where they simply cannot imagine standing up to patriarchy like the author did.

    Think of the author’s response to this incident. She stood up to their bullying because she was educated and she knew her rights. When all women here are educated, when they all know their rights AND when they are no longer economically downtrodden, only then can we expect to see changes in the attitude of the average Pakistani male.

    Good work, Aisha.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*