After watching the abysmal and totally demoralizing defeat of the Pakistani cricket team in the one day international played at Cape Town, South Africa on February 11, 2007 it was quite evident that this team is nowhere close to being called a professional sports outfit. How else could you explain a thumping performance a few days ago in Durban, mixed in with lackluster and even downright pathetic performances during most of the other matches played on this tour?
This does not bode well for the Pakistan team being sent as the hopes of the nation in regaining the coveted World Cup 2007 in the West Indies only a month away. But the World Cup should be the least of our worries.
The real malaise that afflicts the Pakistani cricket team has to do with the more basic issue of professionalism and what it takes to become an international sports team in the highly competitive arena of world cricket. The problem stems from players not working on the basics of their game and relying on raw talent alone to get by. Gone are the days when amateurs would play limited first class games and then be drafted to the national side to learn on the job. Today’s cut-throat world of professional sports demands an ever-improving athlete or he is quickly over-taken by hungrier and younger talent.
Sadly the current Pakistani cricketers do not show the desire or the motivation to constantly improve the deficiencies in their game. Case in point are cricketers like Razzaq, Afridi, and Azhar who have been playing international cricket for almost ten years, with the first two having played more than 200 internationals, and they still repeat some of the same mistakes they made when they first arrived on the scene or have now regressed into bad habits that they fail to rectify.
One of the major reasons for this malaise is the internal politics in the team and the PCB system (or lack thereof) that almost guarantees these players a spot despite their inconsistency and lack of improvement. Newer and younger talent is suppressed after a game or two in the name of stability or citing lack of readiness for international cricket when it is evident that many current players clearly do not perform at an international standard during most matches. Without constant competition from younger and more motivated players, unprofessional and lackluster performances from the chosen bunch are there for all to see.
In any sport when players train or are going through a bad patch, the coaches tell them to go back to basics. Work on your technique and the performance will follow. How many times does Razzaq, a senior player and role model for the younger cricketers, have to get out like he did in the Cape Town match yet he still fails to improve that aspect of his game? How many times does he have to offer those ‘lollipop’ deliveries before his coach (or captain) comes and kicks him on his backside to make him bowl better or be shown the door? How many times does Afridi have to get out by swinging wildly to a nothing ball and then his fanatical admirers say that’s the way he plays so he can be forgiven! These men are hailed as match-winners when their consistency is worse than that of club cricketers or the neighborhood XI.
As Pakistani fans and cricket lovers who spend ridiculous amount of time, money and unbridled energy in watching this sport, we expect (nay demand!) our national cricket team to give their best and to keep improving their game as paid professionals. Most of the senior players on this team are under a PCB contract wherein they are paid monthly retainers (Rs. 200,000) equivalent to 70 times the average monthly income in Pakistan. This is over and above the match fees and some performance incentives that are paid to all players.
Officially, the senior players, if they are fit and play all matches, are earning over Rs. 7-8 million per year! Therefore there is no earthly reason for the public to expect nothing less than their best effort EACH and EVERY time they take the field in the Pakistan colors. This doesn’t mean you perform once or twice in each series, cement your spot in the good books of the captain/coach and then go back to your slumber. In addition, it should be incumbent on every player to constantly work on improving their game.
Are these international players not aware of what sacrifices and training is done to stay competitive and win in world sports today? Do they not see or hear of how Tiger Woods practices his golf swing day and night, all year long? He still gets coached and makes adjustments to his swing, understanding the intricacies of the game, fixing the basics even after he has won all these tournaments and is the undisputed king of golf! Can they not see the videos of Roger Federer practicing diligently and ruthlessly on his serves, volleys, and backhand to stay at #1 in the tennis ranking even after a layperson can see that he is probably the most talented tennis player to have ever graced the sport.
In the cricketing world every fan has heard about the awesome training routines of the Australians and the regimen of some of the best players who constantly strive to improve their game otherwise risk being relegated to the dustbin of world cricket. Imran Khan, the epitome of Pakistan’s cricket glory, writes in his own biography how he took the limited bowling talent he had and trained like a maniac to become one of the greats of all time. Why then do we have to live with the current state of the Pakistani cricket team? We all proclaim them to be hugely talented and they are well-compensated, but they still don’t give us the satisfaction of being the best or the confidence of becoming world beaters with any consistency!
The problem with Pakistani cricket (and the nation in most aspects) is that the basics are all wrong. If Inzimam is a great batsman, who cares if his running between the wickets is terrible or his fielding is shabby. Afridi would be kicked out of any other international team because of his irresponsible batting, poor average and his antics off the field but for Pakistanis he is the “beast” because he will hit one six per game and score a quick-fire fifty once every 20 matches. The under-achieving Razzaq is the same way. We let their pathetic performances slide because of the one moment of glory when they hit McGrath for a six, or clean bowl Tendulkar. No one ponders on the fact that McGrath, Pollock and Tendulkar take them to the proverbial cleaners 90% of the time.
Professionalism demands that you go back to the basics and work on every weak part of your game and it starts from the very top. What the PCB needs to do to become a more professional organization requires a whole other essay but there is nothing stopping each player on his path to professionalism. The basics of training, nutrition, and psychological well-being can be mastered by any of the present cricketers with the resources now available to them.
For Inzimam, it means he improve his fitness and his running between the wickets. It also means he should take lessons from his media-savvy friends (or hire a PR professional) to improve his communication with other teams and the press. God knows he will have a life after cricket. He is the leader of the team and many times its sole spokesman and that is his job.
For Yousuf it may mean he works on his fielding and throwing.
For Asif it requires hiring a nutritionist, taking better care of his body and training how to bowl on flat wickets.
For Afridi, Razzaq and the rest of the team - well it is quite evident what they all need to do to justify the millions being paid to them for representing their country. Since there is no compulsion in cricket, if you can’t do what’s necessary to become a professional cricketer then please spare the nation the embarrassment of another pathetic performance and get another job.
Until and unless the Pakistani cricketers realize what it means to be called a PROFESSIONAL sportsman they should stop saying ‘InshAllah’ we will beat India / Australia / South Africa, or state that we will win the World Cup. Please don’t drag God into cricket when you are not willing to adhere to the standards of a professional sport or the honor of representing your country.
As fans, patriots and well-wishers of Pakistan cricket we deserve better than the schizophrenic nature of our team’s performance. This myopic obsession with the cricket World Cup is akin to asking Tiger Woods to win the Master’s and then forgetting about the PGA tour for the rest of the year. We all hope for our team to win the World Cup but that should not be the solitary standard we hold them accountable to. Great teams are not single tournament winners or flash-in-the-pan performers. The Pakistan team of professional cricketers needs to show up ready and willing for every international series and tournament. When they don the Pakistan greens or the cap, they need to demonstrate to the world that they are the hopes and aspirations of 150 million people and will not go home without a fight.
it’s pretty easy to knock someone when they’re down. but the smart thing to do is look for negatives when things are going well and positives when things are not going well. now is the time to support the team. we’re not going to gain anything by questioning their heart and desire at this stage.
if I remember correctly, you were the guy who wrote an article on chowk a couple of years ago blaming all of Pak cricket’s ills on the PCB. and then suggested that the results could be dramatically improved if the PCB selected the top domestic performers. in reality, the PCB did and does pick some good domestic performers (Rao Iftikhar, Fazl-e-Akbar) and when they do, fans like you and I start crying because we want to see the 90 mph bowler regardless of whether he knows how to bowl simple line and length or not. you can pick an honest trier like Rao or you can pick a gamble like Sami. most fans want to see the latter. and therein lies part of the problem.
so, the issue isn’t as simple as laying the blame on the players or the PCB or the selectors. a little bit of the fault lies with everybody including the fans who have in the past tremendous pressure on the PCB and the selectors to recall players who clearly don’t deserve to play international cricket. you can almost sense when a player is about to be recalled. a whispering campaign is started in the papers, fans’ opinions are cited and before you know it guys like Imran Nazir come back. and the vicious cycle continues.
Zamanov, I’m afraid that your arguments don’t make much cricketing sense. Blaming the entire fiasco on the players is not reasonable. Money does not translate into performance unless it is put into the infrastructure and the development of the sport at lower levels. It does not matter how much money you give to a player, he is still the same player he was without the money. If I give a billion dollars to Aisamul Haq, is he going to be able to beat Roger Federer? ….would he give him a better fight because of the money? It doesn’t work like that.
And whatever resources Pakistan has available, most other teams have more. If you want to play that game, others can play better.
People are quick to point out the players they want thrown out the team but who would they replace them with? Any suggestions?
The only solution to the problems of Pakistani cricket is to nurture more talent by establishing proper cricketing academies at school/local levels and also to build bouncy, live pitches on the domestic circuit: what Imran Khan has been advocating for ages.
Until then, we have to “accept” the reality of Pakistani cricket and be content with occasional bursts of brilliance by random players. After all, we are still rated the 3rd best team in both the Test and ODI forms of the game. That ain’t too bad !
For the tendency of our batting to struggle abroad, I think our flat domestic pitches are to blame. We should make harder pitches and leave some grass so that the ball also seams around a bit. That will force the batsmen to play with proper technique. They get away with poor technique on dead tracks, but are found out on lively piches abroad.
It’s a bit unrealistic to expect them to suddenly change their deeply entrenched habits on foreign tours. If we want good technique, we have to ensure that bad technique is discouraged in our domestic cricket.
The author has a very valid point; we should demand and encourage consistency instead of getting carried away by isolated performances.
But the problem is precisely that our system as well as the attitute of the fans encourages inconsistency.
Like 2003, they will get a drubbing in the world cup, and then everyone will start demanding the sacking of more than half the team, and a rebuilding process will start all over again.
The list of axed players is likely to include Inzi, Rana Naveed, Kamran Akmal, Razaq, Shoab Akhtar (if he isn’t unfit already), Qaneria (from the one day team), and possibly Afridi as well.
Shoaib Actor, M Asif and Umar Gul are all plagued with fitness issues. This leaves pakistan with 2nd tier bowlers. Pakistan’s strength overseas have remained their pace attack, not their batting line-up. This mean pakistan not only cannot win, but in fact don’t *deserve* to win.
I predict srilanka will do much better than both pak and india. NZ and West indies might play a spoiler but they can’t win. in the end it will be down to england or australia.
@Eidee saheb: I would love to see the Pakistan team beat Australia or South Africa on a consistent basis. I believe the acceptance of inconsistency and mediocrity is a defeatist attitude and is exactly what holds back the cricket team. We are not really underdogs (New Zealand or Bangladesh or underdogs!), we are usually the joke of world cricket. Lots of smoke but very little fire.
@Teeth maestro and Rehan: Glad you get the point. As the premier sports team of this beleagured country it can be a role model for change in all matters of organizational behavior.
@Akif Nizam: As I said in the piece this is not about the World Cup. With the money and resources now available in this sport there is no reason why we can’t have a coherent strategy to win consistently (or at least be competitive) outside of the subcontinent. Until when will you keep watching a drubbing on the hands of the top teams till you decide it’s not worth your time?
Good article but you crossed the limits of criticism. This is time to boost their morale because now we don’t have any other option. After the world cup, we need overhauling and I hope somebody will try to fix the system. You are right that it not only cricket team, we as a nation are lazy and lame duck people. We always try to take short cut to achieve our goal. We are leg puller and selfish who don’t care about others and always try to be ahead of others. If we really want to fix the cricket problems, we will have to find the root cause first. In my opinion the real root cause is our government who is not nationalistic and loyal to our country and so all we are.
I understand the anger and frustration but I do not agree with the premise. It’s not a recent phenomenon that the Asian teams underperform overseas on bouncy pitches. The Indian team has only won 27 test matches abroad in their entire history (as opposed to Pakistan’s 44). Is that due to a lack of professionalism on the part of Indians as well?
I agree that there is inadequete coaching in Pakistan and the role of the team coach is more of a personnel manager than anything else. However, it is really hard for an established player to get rid of their bad habits which they have nurtured for decades playing on flat pitches. How can someone change their technique for one month out of the twelve months that they play cricket?
What we are seeing in South Africa is not going to be true for the West Indies where the pitches have less bounce and are more suited to Pakistani batsmen. I do not agree with the contract system as well and think that compensation should be performance based alone. However, the current team does represent the best players we have in the country and replacing them with second string players is not the way to go in my opinion.
Having said that, Pakistan in on their way to another drubbing in the last ODI. All out for 150 odd runs.