Owning Fred Bremner

Posted on February 7, 2011
Filed Under >Pervaiz Munir Alvi, Art & Literature, History, People
Total Views: 131635


Pervaiz Munir Alvi

Fred Bremner was not born or raised in Pakistan. In fact during his life time there was no country on the map by the name of Pakistan. Yet, for thirty five years he lived and worked among, owned studios and properties at, and traveled through out the areas that would later become Pakistan.

He was a commercial photographer who like thousands of other enterprising Britons earned his living by working his trade. But he was one of the pioneers of his art working in Karachi, Quetta, Rawalpindi and Lahore, the four important and major cities of Pakistan today.

He was not a diplomat, historian or a journalist, yet his photographs and publications have become an important source of historic records of the cities, events, places and people in Pakistan. By helping record the history of the late nineteenth and early twentieth century he, however unintentional it may, has rendered important services to what would later become Pakistan.

Yet, in Pakistan there is no mention of his name in history books; no acknowledgement of his work in museums; no art gallery dedicated to him; not even a plaque of his name at his former studios some of which are still in operation. No stamp has ever been issued in his name; no articles are written on him; no seminar has been offered to discuss his work and his contributions in the art of photography in Pakistan. In fact, Pakistan is totally oblivious of him.

It is time that Pakistan acknowledges his art and services and claims him as one of her own and gives him his rightful place in heritage of Pakistan.

Fred Bremner was born in 1863 in a small village of Scotland named Aberchinder, also known as ‘Foggylone’. In 1876 at the age of thirteen he left school and start working with his father who was a professional photographer and owned a studio in the town of Banff, Scotland. In 1882 after having worked for his father for six years he accepted a contract from his brother-in-law, G.W. Lawrie who by that time had owned a studio in Lacknow. So with twenty pounds in his pocket borrowed from his father and passage provided by Lawrie he set sails on a ship named Sutlej to the British Indian Empire. After landing at Bombay he traveled for two days and two nights to reach Lacknow. For the next two years he would work on several assignments at various locations in northern India.

After the first two years, for his next assignment he was sent 1500 miles away to work in Karachi where he arrived via Lahore in summer of 1885. British had captured Karachi in 1839 when it had a population of only ten thousand. However at the time of his arrival Karachi had become an important sea port for overseas commerce for Sindh, Balochistan and Punjab provinces and its population had increased to hundred fifty thousand.

Even though prior to his arrival he did not know a soul in Karachi, he was soon able to meet a Barrack Master Richardson who belonged to the Scottish Lodge of Freemasons, the organization Bremner had joined earlier. Richardson took him as a paying guest and also introduced him to a chemist friend who allowed the young photographer to set up his studio tent in his yard. Bremner worked in this set up for next five months. During this time he also hired two local assistants who helped him with retouching, printing, finishing and hand coloring. At the end of his assignment he left Karachi in 1886 and did not return to the city for the next two years. In April 1888 his contract with Lawrie had ended, his sister had died and he wanted to go home. So he returned to Karachi to take a ship for the British Isles.

In 1889 Bremner returned to Karachi to set up his own business. Through his savings he had bought some equipment from Glasgow and paid for the fair for himself and his one assistant whom he also had brought to Karachi with him. However after paying for all that, he had very little money left to sustain. Luckily a new market had just been inaugurated in Karachi and there were enough townsmen to be photographed to mark the occasion.

Another help came when the Sukher bridge, named after Viceroy Lord Lansdowne across the Indus river was inaugurated on March 25, 1889 by Lord Reay, Governor of the Bombay Province with which Sindh was attached at that time. Bremner had traveled to Hyderabad and then to Sukher to take remarkable photographs of this new magnificent structure. Sensing limited opportunities in Karachi, Bremner decided to explore work possibilities in Quetta which after being captured in 1876 by Lord Robert Sandeman was made capital of Balochistan and by 1889 had become a hub of significant military and political activities.

Journey to Quetta took Bremner through Jacobabad where he was able to pick up more business taking pictures of Cavalry and Infantry men stationed there. While in Quetta he was called upon to photograph the Viceroy who was on a visit there at the invitation of Governor Balochistan, Sir Robert Sandeman. The Khan of Kalat was also invited for the occasion and he too along with male members of his entourage was photographed by Bremner. In Balochistan, Bremner also photographed the Bolan Pass, traveled to border town of Chaman and took pictures of the under construction Khojak or Koh Zak Tunnel near Shelabagh.

In 1892 Bremner closed his Karachi studio and moved to Rawalpindi where he would work in the winter months. The city had become a major garrison town and there was plenty of work taking pictures of military officers and listed men alike. One of his note able subjects was Lord Roberts, Commander-in-Chief of the British Army in India. Around 1895 Bremner was making an album titled ‘Types of the Indian Army’ while based in Rawalpindi. This album had sixty pictures showing men of various ethnicities, races and ranks in groups of four or five together. However in order to complete his project, he had to close his shop one more time and travel back to England.

Upon his return from England Bremner decided to settle in Quetta. In 1900 from Quetta he issued an album of 45 photographs titled ‘Balochistan Illustrated’ featuring people and landscape of that province. While in Quetta he was detected for having heart problems and was advised to return to England but he instead decided to visit Kashmir for few months. He traveled from Quetta to Rawalpindi and then left for Srinagar on a two horse Tonga, crossed river Jhelum by a rope bridge and visited the temples of Murtand on the way. His three months trip to Kashmir allowed him to capture the beauty of the mountain state where he took some of the memorable photos of her people, lakes and mountains alike. Bremner stayed in Quetta for two years and then decided to move again.

This time he moved permanently to Lahore even though he kept his place in Quetta as his summer residence. Lahore as capital of Punjab under British had grown to its Civil and Military prominence. Bremner had got married by now and set up his house and studio in a building opposite to the Roman Catholic Cathedral. From here in 1902 he traveled to Delhi to photograph the pomp and show organized by the Viceroy Lord Curzon to impress the Nawabs and Maharajas he had successfully subjugated earlier.

In 1910 Bremner sold his summer house and business in Quetta in favor of Shimla where he had the opportunity to photograph Lady Eileen Elliot, daughter of Viceroy Lord Minto as well as Viceroy Lord Reading. He had also photographed Lord Hardinge, Lord Chelmsford, Lord Kitchener and Sir Michael O’Dwyer, Governor of Punjab. In 1922 he photographed then Prince of Wales who later became King Edward the VIII. Finally in 1923 he sold his places in both Lahore and Shimla and returned to Elgin, England where he finally published his memoir in 1940. His exact date of death is not known but most likely he died in 1941 and was survived by a son.

Acknowledgement: The factual information in this essay is taken from a larger essay “Bremner’s Indian Years” by Brij Bhushan Sharma. The photographs here are linked from, and more are avilable at Harappa.com. We are thankful to Harappa.com for so elegantly preserving this heritage. Click on pictures to get details on the picture.

22 Comments on “Owning Fred Bremner”

  1. hakim says:
    January 10th, 2007 9:06 am

    Very interesting article. What I truly admired about the Western people is their ‘adventure’ gene. They really love going to far away places to explore without any qualms about being alone. Their independence allows them to really dig deep into a culture and learn the smallest details of it. Obviously, with the ‘adeventure’ gene comes the ‘drama’ gene and most of what they do outside their countries is turned into a drama inside their countries. They’re great showmen willing to go really far for a show.

  2. January 10th, 2007 10:45 am

    Pervaiz Sahib,
    Do you recommend any books with photographs taken during those times. Last week I saw a book called ‘The Dual City – Karachi – during the Raj’ at the PC Hotel in Karachi but I was not very impressed with pictures of ordinary people and their lives. The pictures of the architecture were wonderful though.

  3. Samdani says:
    January 10th, 2007 10:51 am

    Great photographs and a very informative writeup about someone I had not known about. I totally agree that we should own all elements of our history and heritage and this photographic record of his is a great reminder of an era that we are otherwise told little about. I guess this site is doing something that Ken Burns did for the US on PBS but highlighting the non-traditional sources of history.

    I hope someone in power reads this and takes on the idea of honoring him somehow. Maybe a room with his photographs in the Lahore Museum or the National Library in Islamabad.

  4. khalid says:
    January 10th, 2007 1:55 pm

    Very interesting article, Pakistan government should honor him for all his work.Through photography he has preserved history of important events of his time.If his son is alive he should be contacted and should be thanks for his father work.

  5. Salima says:
    January 10th, 2007 6:05 pm

    This is an amazing record of our history.

    Love the picture of Karachi, what a sleepy little town it looks like.

    I think the idea of owning and honoring people like Fred Bremner is a good one. It does not take much and shows the full scope of our history. It would be nice to have a permanent display of his work somewhere in Pakistan. Maybe Mohatta?

  6. MQ says:
    January 10th, 2007 9:18 pm

    Great photographs! As Hakim said earlier one cannot help but marvel at the adventurous spirit of these Westerners who would go to all these faraway places and write about or photograph them.

    Interestingly, one doesn’t see a single person in these pictures — young or old — without a turban.

  7. Pervaiz Munir Alvi says:
    January 11th, 2007 9:08 am

    Friends: Thank you for the encouraging comments. Much of the credit for this post goes to Dr. Adil and his team. Posts on this site are always a team effort.

    Mr. Zuberi: I have a book in my library by F.S. Aijazuddin “Historical Images of Pakistan” printed by Ferozsons. It is a good read.

    Samdani: You and I are on the same page on this subject. I get ideas to write from my own ignorance of my own country and of my own people. So inadequate was my education growing up in Pakistan. We teach very little to our children.

    Khalid: We should not Wait for our government to preserve our history. Fred Bremner has been recognised and honored by his native Scotland for his work. It is time for us Pakistanis to do the same.

    Salima: Mohatta Palace or Lahore Museum will be a good place to host the work of Fred Bremner and his contemporaries in Pakistan.

    MQ: Bremner had habit of placing local people in their customary garb in his pictures for the native affect.

  8. Akram Zaidi says:
    January 15th, 2007 11:33 pm

    A book of similar interest is From Kashmir to Kabul: The Photographs of Burke and Baker 1860-1900. It is very beautiful and informative.

  9. Omar Khan says:
    April 3rd, 2007 4:47 pm

    As the person who published the essay on Bremner on my website, and with access to a number of his images, I’d be happy to work with anyone interested in doing an exhibition in Pakistan of them. Bremner’s photographic career covers much of Pakistan, especially Sindh and Balochistan, which most other photographers missed. It would be very nice to blow-up the images and display them at a place like Mohatta Palace or elsewhere.

  10. Peter Hillin says:
    May 12th, 2007 10:25 am

    I’m from Banff scotland and stumbled across the article by accident, fascinating.

    A few points Bremner was born in Aberchirder (an understandable spelling mistake) which is only 10 miles (15Km’s) from banff. The name Bremner is extremly common in this area and I would not be suprised if his descendants still lived in the area. The alternative name of the town known in the main only to local people is Foggie or Foggieloan, derived from an old croft which existed before the town came into being.

    Elgin where he died is in Scotland and is about 35 miles from where he was born. next time I’m in Elgin I may visit the local cemetry to see where his grave is situated.

  11. Mark Montgomery says:
    November 6th, 2007 12:51 am

    Fred Bremner died on 03 September 1941 at 4, Bridge Street, Aberdeen. His usual residence was Oakbank, Elgin. He was survived by Emily Bremner, his second wife.

  12. December 24th, 2007 5:31 am

    Quetta earthquake of 1935 its photographs took all of us by strom in utter disbelief of ground realities as told by our parents when some of our near & dear ones suffered irreparable losses in terms of life & property.Our shop at Anderson Road, House in Bhagmal St., Godown at Bruce Road,all were destroyed and forgotten but chance tracing of roots through this site & its pics has created a feeling of rebirth in that period_salute to people of Quetta.

  13. January 12th, 2008 6:36 pm

    Thank you for revealing the “lost history” that most Pakistanis don’t know. I was searching for Quetta pics when I came across this article.
    Here are my photos from my recent Quetta trip:

  14. January 12th, 2008 6:49 pm

    And the weird thing for me was that I was familiar with http://harappa.com and http://mohenjodaro.net/ but I only knew about the pictures of the ancient remains at these sites, I never looked at the links for the 19th century photos of Indo-Pak.

  15. June 3rd, 2008 2:00 am

    It good info, special concering Balouchistan and Khan of Kalat.

    If you need more info, you can easily get it from us, and the photos as well.

    Success and progress in your work

    Changgaiz Khan

  16. Asadullah says:
    June 29th, 2008 11:04 am

    Wow. Amazing collection of pictures and a beautiful post. Thank you for this.

  17. ShahidnUSA says:
    June 29th, 2008 1:33 pm

    Thanks to Mr Pervaiz Munir Alvi and this SITE for bringing this up.

  18. June 29th, 2008 5:53 pm

    incredible, let’s say we were oblivious of him, ATP changed it. Hey Fred we know you now – kinda happy! ;)

  19. Pervaiz Munir Alvi says:
    June 30th, 2008 8:32 am

    Owais Sahab: Thank you for bringing back this post to the ‘Front Page’. Since its first posting eighteen months ago a new group of readers has joined ATP community. I hope the new readership enjoys this post as well. Some of the commenters from Scotland have made additions/corrections to the post and I am thankful to them for their contributions. Pakistan and its Indus Valley has a heritage of five thousand years. Her people need to embrace and own ALL of it. If we did not define our self, others will.

  20. Omar Khan says:
    July 3rd, 2008 10:15 am

    Yes, it is good to remind people of the rich visual history of Pakistan. A new site, ImagesofAsia.com has over 120 restored vintage images of Pakistan, including some by Fred Bremner, and I understand many more unseen Bremner images are on their way. There are also a number of other unknown photographers represented there, early photographers of Murree and elsewhere that remain largely unknown.

  21. Jawed says:
    February 8th, 2011 8:41 am

    A gem of a post. Thanks for sharing this.

  22. DERVISH says:
    February 8th, 2011 3:32 pm

    Excellent post, real good effort. welldone.

Have Your Say (Bol, magar piyar say)