Mr. Jinnah in Caricature is More Real

Posted on December 25, 2007
Filed Under >Adil Najam, Education, History, People
24 Comments
Total Views: 96395

Adil Najam

Today, December 25, marks the birth anniversary of Pakistan’s founder, Mohammad Ali Jinnah. Mr. Jinnah has been a subject of frequent, and sometimes heated, discussion on ATP (here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here and here). Maybe it is best to spare him the agony of argumentation on his birthday.

Instead, we wish to share this rather interesting and apt tribute to him (supposedly, the first in a series) by Dawn newspaper. (Click on image for larger image).

Jinnah's life . Dawn newspaper

Dawn newspaper is currently celebrating its own and Pakistan’s 60th anniversary and as part of this celebration will carry a series of illustrated episodes from Mr. Jinnah’s life. This one, the first in this series, is illustrated by Syed Salman Nasir.

I, for one, liked this very much. As readers know I have always liked Jinnah the human even more than Quaid-i-Azam the icon. I also think that this type of story-telling might appeal to the young far more than staid narrations.

Given how our official portraits of Mr. Jinnah tend to be over-stylized and how the national discourse on his is more iconic than human, it is interesting (to say the least) that his human side (see here and here) emerges much more clearly in this caricature than it does in most of our national discussions about him.

24 responses to “Mr. Jinnah in Caricature is More Real”

  1. Watan Aziz says:

    Pakistaniat has both marbles and cricket, guli-danda and hockey.

    No?

    Seems the editor or the cartoonist has a dislike for marbles, as there was no need to bring that up in this manner. I particularly do not care, just thinking that if we have had distorted image of Jinnah before now, it looks to me it is fully hijacked in this rendition!

    BTW, this ‘back-to-the-future’ genre was used by Akbar Ahmed’s Jinnah (http://www.chowk.com/articles/12244). A must see movie for all interested in Pakistaniat. And I also highly recommend his book.

  2. Daktar says:

    Sorry for the double message. But does anyone know how frequently and when more episodes will appear?

  3. Daktar says:

    I like this a lot. I think Dawn is onto something important in humanizing the Quaid. How can you go wrong with cricket. Great idea.

  4. Malique says:

    Its high time to human-ise our Azam-ish Jinnah.His personality has been made so controversial and so has been the case with his sayings,courtesy of the syllabus specially modified for the students of “Islamic Republic of Pakistan”-that he never founded!

  5. Bilal Zuberi says:

    Fascinating. Young kids learn so many of life’s lessons from such cartoon images than they would with Quaid’s farmaans relayed before the 9 PM news.
    It is not only important that we see Jinnah, probably our only undisputed, non-discredited, leader as a person, but it is necessary for our political health as a nation. We need to also be able view today’s leaders as humans first…and judge how they rate before us as people and individuals, before what their famous last names stands for.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*