In a short verdict today, Supreme Court of Pakistan has disqualified PML(N) leader Nawaz Sharif and the Chief Minister Punjab Shehbaz Sharif from contesting any election for life. The detailed verdict will be announced later.
The decision technically knocks out two top leaders of one the largest political party of Pakistan, PML(N). It also means that Shehbaz Sharif is no longer the Chief Minister of Punjab and his cabinat has also been dismissed.
The situation in the province and the country is now very tense and the President, Prime Minister and Federal Ministers are all discussing options. There is also talk that the PPP may now formally contact PML(Q) to form a government in the Punjab.
In latest news, Governor-rule was imposed in the Punjab, with the Governor of the Punjab, Salman Taseer taking over as Chief Executive of the province. The decision has sparked angry protests in various cities of Punjab including Lahore, Faisalabad, Guranwala some damage has been caused to public property on Mall Road.
We will have to wait and see the level of political turmoil this verdict creates. Without going into merits of the decision, I think it will create more political instability and uncertainty which is the last thing we want to see in Pakistan. It is rather unfortunate but the initial reactions and statements suggests that Pakistan might be heading towards the politics of confrontation and horse-trading of 1990s.
According to Geo TV:
The three-member Bench of Supreme Court has disposed off Sharif brothers’ electoral eligibility case by declaring them ineligible for contesting elections in its two-line short order announced here. Shahbaz Sharif under this verdict has lost his seat in the provincial assembly and being no longer member of the Punjab House, he is no more Punjab chief minister, as SC has annulled the earlier notification about his being chief minister.
This case was under hearing of the SC three-member Bench headed by Justice Musa K. Laghari for the last eight months, in which, the Attorney General of Pakistan, Latif Khosa giving his arguments said that Punjab chief secretary and speaker were not the party in the case. Attorney General said that all the judges have taken oaths under the constitution and talking about the oath of the interim constitution was irrelevant.
He said that Nawaz Sharif’s proposer and seconder could become parties in the case if the court permits them and their becoming parties was not necessary. He further said that it was the discretion of the judge to withdraw from the Bench and no one could direct him to pull out.
On conclusion of the arguments, after a short break, the Bench disposing off the Sharif brothers’ eligibility case declared them ineligible.
Following the verdict, Sharif brothers’ lawyer, Akram Sheikh told media that the decision was as expected, as the government was giving dictation to the judges. He said that Sharif brothers were declared ineligible on the orders of President Zardari. He said that the judges would be made accountable on the Day of Judgement. Akram Shiekh said that now it was up to the people to decide if the verdict was on merit. He said that he couldn’t comment on the incomplete two-line judgment. This decision would be presented as bouquet to President Asif Zardari on his return from the China tour.
ML-N workers in sizable number were present on the occasion of the announcement of verdict raising slogans in favour of long march and Sharif brothers. Security arrangement remain tightened in the capital city here.
What this means for Lawyers Movement, the upcoming Long March, relations between Punjab and the Federation and the overall political as well as economic situation of Pakistan and most importantly for the ordinary people of Pakistan? I am afraid we will just have to wait and see. Not a good day for ordinary People of Pakistan in my view.
Nawaz Sharif, whatever he was in the past, has turned into a good politician. I respect him for standing with the lawyers movement despite several losses to him and his party. To leave the cabinet is unprecedented and now even when he has to loose his government he seems firm on his stand.
Another great leader, (Shahbaz) wasted in political bickering and by controlled judiciary. Shahbaz Sharif has been an exemplary CM of Punjab, is this what we do to our leader who deliver? The irony is that Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto was the leader of PPP (ruling party now) when the same Judiciary was used to end him.
Very Unfortunate!
Since March 2007, Pakistani political classes (and that includes the military) have not been able to settle the Judges issues. That sword of Democles hung over Mushrarraf, just as it hangs over the current system.
I wish the issue is settled, one way or another, very soon. Until then, the disqualification of the Sharif Brothers makes this another sad day in the history of Pakistan.
This certainly ranks up there among the top misdeeds of the supreme court along with the doctrine of necessity, justifying martial law, the hanging of Bhutto, leading to Zia’s maulvi islam doctrine which we are all paying for right now, and now this: the negation of democracy and the peoples right to choose their leaders.
wither the wisdom one is supposed to ask of the judiciary. but what can you expect when they put their self-interest and self-preservation ahead of the country.
Nawaz Sharif is a crook, a kidnapper and a hijacker. Supreme Court has made the right decision.
Unfortunately for Pakistan, it is heading straight back to the confrontational politics of the 1990’s. Welcome to democracy.