Adil Najam
Punjab Member of Provincial Assembly (MPA) Shumaila Rana, of the PML-N, has been arrested by the Punjab police for allegedly stealing two credit cards and then going on a shopping spree with them. The PML-N leadership has said that the law will take its course. But this adds one more shocking story to what is already a litany of sorts.
The details are bizarre enough not to need an explanation. According to the Daily Times:
Ghalib Market police on Sunday registered a case against a Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) female MPA for allegedly stealing two credit cards from a woman’s wallet and buying jewelery and clothes worth Rs 80,000 on those cards, the police said. The FIR No 551/09 was registered against the MPA under Section 379 of the Pakistan Penal Code (PPC), on the complaint of Muqeet Salam, brother-in-law of Zaira Malik of Canal Bank.
The police said the accused MPA Shumaila Anjum Rana could not be contacted so far… He said Salam alleged in the application that his sister-in-law Zaira was in a fitness club on July 7 and found her credit cards missing from her purse. He said Zaira contacted the bank officials concerned who informed her that transactions worth Rs 80,000 had been made on her credit cards. Salam said the banks also informed Zaira that the accused purchased goods from a shop in Siddique Trade Centre.
The police quoted the complainant as saying that the shop owner showed the recorded CCTV footage to them and finally Zaira identified Shumaila, who is not a member of the club. He said they had also received the records of transactions in which Malik’s credit cards were used.
Interestingly, The Nation reports that Ms. Rana is a member of the Punjab Assembly Standing Committee on Religious Affairs and Auqaf, and more importantly, that she is also a member of Chief Minister’s Coordination Committee for the IDPs which deals with the Punjab Chief Minister’s Fund for the IDPs of NWFP.
The report in The Nation provides more context information:
This time it is not a male parliamentarian, rather to jump into the already-boiling fray of irregularities and illegalities by elected representatives is a female MPA, Shumaila Rana, who was ‘chosen’ on reserved seats to serve the masses. The Pakistan Muslim League-N has vowed to fulfil all legal formalities in investigating the case. On the other hand, if found guilty, she will lose her seat, as no convicted can become a parliamentarian, and stands disqualified as conviction as per the Articles 62 and 63 of the Constitution.
Previously, it were MNA Haji Pervaiz Khan from Rawalpindi and Minister Prisons Ch Abdul Ghafoor of the N-League, who indulged in impersonation and acted highhandedly at the Lahore Airport respectively. Interestingly, the MNA lost his seat after a committee found him guilty, and the Minister was given honourable exit from the charges by the PML-N leadership despite the fact that the committee found him guilty on more than two accounts. Prior to Shumaila Rana’s case, another N-League’s MPA Munawar Gill was indicted in a rape case. He is said to have been found innocent in the case.
The first timer to the Punjab Assembly Shumaila Rana, reportedly found guilty of stealing credit card from another female’s bag, and indulging in ‘illegal’ shopping, is member of the Standing Committee on Religious Affairs and Auqaf. Moreover, she is also member of Chief Minister’s Coordination Committee for the Internally-Displaced People, which is an offshoot of Punjab Chief Minister’s Fund for the IDPs of NWFP.
Unmarried Shumaila Rana is daughter of Hidayat Ali, and she climbed the ladder of becoming an MPA by virtue of her mother Anjum Ara’s services to the party, as the latter has been worker of the party for about two decades. Anjum Rana, a retired schoolteacher of a private institute, was not a graduate, and after her successful canvassing for her daughter, a reserved seat was given to Shumaila Rana, who is said to be in her mid-20s. She is the first MPA from this family, and has nothing tangible to her credit for which she should have been given the slot. MPA with humble family background, she has been a vociferous supporter of women rights, and their empowerment. She had also promised to lobby for the charter of demands presented by women farmers recently.
The free media in Pakistan has been a mixed blessing. But in cases of corruption, like this one, they have proven to be very useful. Let’s see if the PML-N takes action in this case. Signs suggest that they will.
I, too, am concerned with the comments on the ATP facebook page. Some posters have gone so far as to call for her to be executed, among other harebrained ideas. I’m glad the blog posters remain committed to a reasonable debate and dialogue. In one sense, it’s a good thing that the readership demographics of the facebook page and the blog don’t overlap. If that were to occur, the level of discourse here would plummet, and I imagine, many older posters will not write their comments any longer.
hmm……..I remember my classes in the college , retrograd, while I have been reading the case regarding this lady.
My teacher who was not a muslim asked us in the class :
“What can You my class mention as parameters characterizing being a human living called Homo Sapiens and what characterizes being a a citizen in a society ?? “.
As he asked this we all the pupils thought it was a question, so we started reflecting and bowing and twisting our grey cells in the cerebrum (and as circumstances were , it looked like some of my class-mates used their grey cells in the cerebellum as well..).
But the question was only rhetorically used for the purpose of his brilliant going through this from alpha to omega.
Amongst much he said `a society will disintegrate if those in power be those ; generals, judges from the courts, the police and the elected by the people think that they themselves are above the constitution/law……
It is a categorical imperative from the ethical and morally point of view as I have been telling You (my class) about S
When the head of the PML-N is a crook and hijacker, who stole money from the awam based on various schemes, whether it be taxi-cab, whether it be karz-utaro scheme, or whether it be freezing of foreign currency accounts, then the crime this lady is accused of is minor.
Both should be punished.
Yes admittedly she has been caught with her hand in the cookie jar. But a part of me do feel sorry for her. Here you are, a girl in her impressionable mid twenties, from a very modest back ground and midst of typical punjabi/lahoree vulgar exhibitionism and displays of stolen wealth ——she could not resist the temptation and fell down with her face down in a momentary lapse of judgement.
Ours is a kleptocracy–the current president a known thief, the previous president and prime minister well rounded plunderers—heck even the ”mohatarma shaheed” could never explain the narco-dealer lifestyle she enjoyed in several capitals of the world. If you think that was not stolen money–you probably don’t know enough about birds and bees.
Shumaila’s Rana’s fault is she that stole petty and insanely low amount of money. She deserves letting go and perhaps only a slap on the wrist.
Its like your five year old picking/stealing up a toy from her friend’s bedroom and bringing it home.
I must say I find this story very distressing. But even more disgusting than what she id is the tone of many of the comments from facebook that you give.
The venom and choota-pun and arrogance in those comments is truly disgusting. Maybe, we do deserves people like her after all!