Last two days have been dramatic in Pakistani politics. Since February Elections, we have been hearing good news, atleast on political fronts. It seemed that Pakistan is finally moving towards national reconciliation and this time politicians are really coming together and serious about solving public problems. But things have suddenly changed since yesterday. In separate and unfortunate incidents, two senior members of Musharraf regime, who also happened to be his most vocal supporters, have been severely beaten up and humiliated in public. 
Yesterday, it was the former Chief Minister of Sindh, Arbab Ghulam Rahim beaten up in assembly by angry protesters and today it was Dr. Sher Afgan Niazi’s turn who was the minister of Parliamentary Affairs. Arbab Ghulam Rahim was slapped and beaten up by angry protesters. He was slapped and hit with shoes while he was coming to take oath in newly elected Sindh assembly. Apparently, one of the culprits, who hit him with his shoes turned out to be his staff member who served him for four years when he was CM. A large number of lawyers laid a siege around the office of Dr. Afgan’s lawyer, with eggs, tomatoes and their shoes in their hands, when he came to visit him. He was then severely beaten up with shoes and slapped when police finally tried to rescue him out of his lawyer’s office.
No matter much you dislike both gentlemen, this kind of violence in politics is not acceptable. Mr. Sher Afgan has already been punished by his people of his constituency who rejected him in elections because of his ugly role in Judicial Crises and his abusive statements against Lawyers movement. This show of violence coming from Lawyers community, who are supposed to protect and defend human rights is shocking. Aitezaz Ahsen, who tried his best save him from serious beating, and other lawyers leaders are calling it a planned scheme by non-democratic forces to damage their cause and to put hurdles in restoration of deposed judges.
According to Geo TV:
Former federal minister, Dr. Sher Afgan Niazi has been rescued safely by President Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) Aitezaz Ahsan.
Enraged lawyers tore up Dr. Afgan’s clothes and attacked him by throwing stones and shoes.
They also shaterred the windows of the ambulance in which Dr. Afgan was being taken away from the site of the incident.
Earlier, a large number of lawyers laid a siege around the office of Dr. Afgan’s lawyer when he came to visit him.
The police present at the scene failed to create a safe passage for Dr. Afgan and he remained confined in the office for about three hours.
Later, President SCBA Aitezaz Ahsan arrived here to control the situation and disperse the lawyers.
Although he asked the enraged lawyers and others to leave the place, they continued to wait for Dr. Afgan to come out.
Later, Dr. Afgan came out of the building and escorted by Aitezaz Ahsan. Struggling through the crowd they made their way to an Edhi ambulance with the help of police.
As soon as Dr. Afgan got inside the ambulance, Aitezaz Ahsan mounted the rooftop of the vehicle which was then driven slowly away from the crowd.
Later, Aitezaz Ahsan resigned from the post of SCBA President.
DAWN filed this story on Dr. Arbab Ghulam Rahim’s incident:
Despite strong police protection provided to him by the caretaker administration, the former chief minister of Sindh, Dr Arbab Ghulam Rahim, was on Monday physically attacked by some enraged political activists as he left the Assembly after taking the oath as a newly-elected MPA.
The incident was vociferously condemned although it was not unprecedented: in the past, MPA Yunus Khan suffered worse.
The violent episode occurred despite the fact that security was beefed up after Saturday, when Dr Rahim was unable to take the oath because of political activists’ attempts to manhandle him. Subsequently, the Assembly authorities cancelled all passes except those issued to the press.
Slogan-chanting political activists also harassed television reporters and anchorpersons who, despite displaying cards issued by the Assembly authorities, were obstructed from performing their duties.
The MQM played an important role in Dr Rahim’s oath-taking, due to which the session started late. The first attempted assault occurred as the former chief minister sat on the opposition benches next to the Speaker’s gallery, waiting to be administered the oath by the outgoing Speaker, Syed Muzaffar Hussain Shah. An unidentified man, who was later overpowered by some PPP workers and security personnel in plainclothes, hurled a shoe at Dr Rahim as the naat was being recited.
Meanwhile, political activists shouted slogans against the former chief minister and used rude and abusive language, despite warnings issued by the Speaker.
Police and other security official escorted Dr Rahim to the Assembly hall via its back door. He took the oath amid all the chaos and then left the House.
Although a strong security cover had been provided by the caretaker Home adviser and the Assembly authorities to the former chief minister upon his arrival, it appeared to have melted away by the time he left the House after taking the oath. As a result, a handful of PPP MNAs had to intervene in the corridor outside the Members’ Gallery to protect Dr Rahim from the wrath of charged workers who allegedly belonged to the PPP.
As he attempted to leave the Assembly, Dr Rahim was struck by a shoe hurled by a political activist. Meanwhile, some women who were displaying similar intentions were pushed back by MPAs and plainclothes security personnel. Even as Dr Rahim was being driven away, his car was chased by charged activists who then vented their anger by targeting the waiting police vehicles.
It remains unclear how such disruptive element managed to obtain passes to gain entry into the Sindh Assembly premises.
PPP distances itself
The Muttahida Qaumi Movement staged a walkout from the Sindh Assembly in protest over the incident, while the Speaker tendered an apology to Dr Rahim. The newly-elected Speaker, Nisar Khuhro, also termed the incident ‘uncalled for’ and urged everyone present to respect the sanctity of the Assembly and allow the provincial legislature to perform its duty.
Deploring the attack, Dr Rahim claimed that it was part of a well-planned conspiracy to harm his person. ‘Such acts are contrary to the spirit of democracy and [the maxim of] live and let live,’ he maintained. ‘The ones who indulged in violence such as this are unwilling to tolerate the voice of dissent in the House and in the province.’
Meanwhile, the PPP distanced itself from the incident, which it termed a plot against the party by involving certain PPP (SB) workers.Condemning the episode in a press statement issued from the Bilawal House media cell, the PPP clarified that the outgoing government still controlled the police and administration and was implementing the orders of the former rulers through the Provincial Police Officer and the Capital City Police Officer.
Calling for the immediate suspension of the PPP Sindh and the CCPO Karachi, the statement said: ‘Even today, the administrative machinery and police were given full authority to control entry into the Sindh Assembly; under special strategy some PPP(SB) workers were smuggled into the Assembly premises to commit the incident.’
A PPP legislator, Manzoor Wassan, told the BBC that the man who hurled his shoe at the former chief minister in the house had been in the service of Dr Rahim for more than four years.
I blame Nawaz sharif and his brother Shahbaz Sharif. I think they started these dirty tricks long back . They have been so consistent against Musharraf. They have mission and they went too far.I am 99% sure NS and SS are behind this , Even PPP better be careful from these brothers.
A day before the prime minister takes oath justice Ramday’s house in Islamabad is broken in and the household effects are dumped out on the street leading to the lawyers’ protests the for next two days.
A day before the Sindh chief minister takes oath Arbab Rahim is beaten up in Sindh Assembly leading to MQM’s boycott of the Assembly and the consequent uproar inside and outside the house.
A day before the Punjab Assembly takes oath Sher Afgan Niazi is beaten up in Lahore giving rise to a widespread turmoil in the country.
One hopes it is all a coincidence and things would settle down soon.
The two sides, especially the ruling coalition, need to stop blaming “conspiracies” and the leadership of each party, and step up and accept responsibility for their workers actions, denounce them and take whatever action they can (expulsion from the party, the bar etc.).
The lawyers are not saints, Aitzaz Ahsan is dropping in my estimation every day he keeps talking about “conspiracies”. If it was merely a conspiracy he wouldn’t have bothered resigning. That he did, even if token, means he knew it was the layers who were responsible.
Accept your faults, rectify them and move on – that is the only way to break from the past.
Too many people are trying to pigeonhole this into “did the ruling coalition do this” or “did Musharraf loyalists do this”.
The fact of the matter is that the leadership on either side does not want this sort of thuggery happening. WE need to face up to the reality that civil discourse is a misnomer in Pakistan – whether its a disagreement over a perception of being overcharged at a store, or politics, Pakistanis give in tho their basest instincts.
We are reared to imbibe machismo – honor and respect shall be preserved by one even if it means taking the law into ones hands, and physical assaults to redress such perceived grievances are part of our culture.
I’ll always remember an incident that took place when I was an adolescent – my father had returned from Pakistan on a business trip and was narrating the story of how all the equipment in his office in Pakistan was missing. The caretaker was missing, but my father tracked him down and gave him the thrashing of his life, at the end of which he confessed and apologized for stealing and selling the stuff.
I remember my father proudly puffing out his chest while talking of this “thrashing”, while our guest silently listened.
At the end, he merely said, and what did the thrashing accomplish?
I’ll never forget the look on my fathers face at that moment. Needless to say, while I respect him and love him dearly still, that is one attribute of his that I have always striven to keep out of my life.
If parties don’t have any control over their workers …. could they stop them from corruption? Between, what about the dialogs between MQM and PPP? No results? violence in Karachi?
Either Zardari or Sharif, no one learned any lesson from past.