Pakistan Kafkaistan: Where the Absurd is always Normal

Posted on May 6, 2007
Filed Under >Raza Rumi, History, People, Politics, Society
34 Comments
Total Views: 21879

Raza Rumi

Raza RumiFranz KafkaThe current political dramas, uncertainty and confusion seem to be extraordinary. But is this really that unusual?

History, if anything, has prepared us for the bizarre and the peculiar. I was therefore prompted to jog my memory and dig out snippets that remain semi-buried in my fallible mind.

Colonel Ilahi Bux, the personal physician of Quaid-e Azam M.A. Jinnah recounted in his little book, With the Quaid-e-Azam During His Last Days, how our executive machinery treated the Quaid when he returned to Karachi after his recuperation in Ziarat. This is a scene from Marquez, the head of state, Governor General and Pakistan’s real, and perhaps the only principled advocate lying in a broken ambulance on a road side and the Madar-i-Millat (mother–of–the–nation), his sister, waving a copy of the newspaper to keep the heat and flies away! And this was no ordinary VIP. The rescue ambulance arrived hours later but the damage had been done.

Mohammad Ali JinnahFatima JinnahLiaquat Ali KhanHuseyn Shaheed Suhrawardhy
Ayub KhanZulfiqar Ali BhuttoGeneral Yahya KhanGeneral Zia ul Haq

Beyond belief? Yes.

The Quaid passed away in 1948, and his Prime Minister, Liaquat Ali Khan, was shot down by a “lunatic” in 1951. To date, we have no clue as to who hatched the conspiracy, with what motive and why the first Prime Minister was brutally murdered. The assassin was overpowered and killed in the melee that immediately followed the killing. Later the investigating officer’s plane went down with the case files. Thus, we shall never find out the truth; and that is extraordinary. Alas, there is no Oliver Stone here to produce a film on this assassination. Even Kafka, whose vision the Pakistani officialdom typifies, would have been shocked at such developments.Madar-i-Millat Fatima Jinnah’s radio address on Jinnah’s anniversary was censored due to a “technical” glitch. Later, she dared to challenge the Army Chief Ayub Khan in the 1965 Presidential race. Syed Sharifuddin Pirzada, another “extraordinary” legal phenomenon of Pakistan, has held time and again that Fatima Jinnah did not die a natural death but was murdered. 

He could be wrong, but do we care?

The great Bengali Prime Minister, Husain Shaheed Suharwardy, believed in the future of a united Pakistan. A capable lawyer, politician and a man of letters, he never gave up even after losing his political space. And, what happened in 1963? Suharwardy was found dead in a Beirut hotel in mysterious circumstances. We are not graceful enough to remember him let alone determine the cause of his death. Extraordinary by all means.

Our history makers were not content with such magic-macabre realism. So, “we” decided to initiate army action against our most populous province in 1970. The West Pakistani elites (and this includes everyone and his uncle in the power circles) refused to hand over power to the majority party from the Eastern wing. So while blaming the Hindu teachers in Bengal and ridiculing the treacherous non–martial race, we were relieved to give away the one province that had in real terms struggled for Pakistan. There was a long period of amnesia and silence slightly stirred by the publication of the Hamood ur Rahman Commission Report (that exposed the army action) in 2000 and an apology tendered by General Musharraf in Dhaka later. UNESCO now celebrates the International Mother Language Day on February 21 every year in commemoration of the Bangla language riots of 1952. Ironies don’t shock us anymore.

In the 1970s we lived happily-ever-after under the ostensibly democratic rule of Mr Bhutto that culminated in his physical elimination through the judicial process. The basis of his sentence was evidence that sensible jurisprudence will consider unreliable and defective. The weekly Economist then ran a cover story titled “We Also Hang Our Prime Ministers.” Decades later, a Freudian remark of a Supreme Court judge (who later served as the Chief Justice) in a TV interview in 2004 failed to shock us when he said that this was kinda mistake. Doctrine of necessity stretched beyond the Kafka-esque limits!

The succeeding ruler, another General, proved to be even more peculiar. Having shaken the social and political foundations of the country for eleven years, Zia ul Haq left the world in bizarre circumstances: uniformed with stars, a copy of the Holy Book on his lap, a Jewish US Ambassador by his side, riding in an army plane and yet blown up in the summer heat of 1988. We added it to the layer of our tormented memories.

The film noir played during the decade of the 1990s starred “democratic” regimes playing hide and seek, displaying a wee-bit more maturity than high school governing bodies. Strange was the murder of a sitting Prime Minister’s brother in 1996; and to make matters worse, the PM herself was implicated in this gory act by none other than her self-appointed cronies!

Sordid as this was, the attack of political workers on the Supreme Court in 1997 made the Chief Justice leave his courtroom and hide. More mind-boggling was the split within the Supreme Court then, as judges passed judgments against each other with abandon. Extraordinary that a part of the current judiciary defenders’ brigade includes some of the stalwarts who ordered or ransacked the Supreme Court making Pakistan appear as a fiefdom from medieval history.

Let’s end with the extraordinary events of October 1999 when the Prime Minister and his close confidants apparently prepared a sub-jail for the serving military chief, without an inquiry of course, and actually believed that they could execute this Alice in Wonderland plan of removing and locking him up!

Welcome to Pakistan, Mr. Kafka.

Raza Rumi blogs at Jahane Rumi and writes for The Friday Times, where this was first published.

34 responses to “Pakistan Kafkaistan: Where the Absurd is always Normal”

  1. Watan Aziz says:

    Did we get where we are by mistake?

    And more importantly, what is being done, besides the talk, to drain the swamps?

  2. yussra says:

    i cant forget bhutto.they r awesome i also want 2 become politician like them
    thanks

  3. vishwanath mishra says:

    hi, i m an indian.
    i saw ur report.it is really an eyeopener to pakistani citizens.
    india 2 is not very fare at political level. political murders take place here, but inspite of all that here courts r doing their duty and politicians fear from court. again the free press is doing it’s duty, so it is unsafe for politicians.
    the ordianary muslims r very innocent and they become target by politicians everywhere in pakistan and in india, in the name of ISLAM and what happend in pakistan , as ur report sayz every dictator won and elected by people.

  4. Anwar says:

    Thanks Raza and Aqil. If we look back we will find that Pakistan’s participation in SETO, CENTO, Columbo Plan, and later in RCD was a product of our foreign policy of 1947 onwards..
    I have a lot of respect for Liaqat Ali Khan however it was during his time Pakistan got hitched with US. Establishment of US Air Force base in Badaber, Peshawar was another factor that invited the wrath of Soviet Union.(U2 used to fly from Peshawar – Garry Powel after being shot down admitted in Moscow.)
    Clearly, Pakistan’s dilema is the lack of statesmenship and good leadership. I have some thoughts on that subject but will leave it for future posting.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*