Emergency “Lifted”: Three Steps Back, Half a Step Forward

Posted on December 15, 2007
Filed Under >Adil Najam, Politics
Total Views: 40835

Adil Najam

Musharraf Drops his UniformThe Emergency that Gen. Pervaiz Musharraf had imposed on November 3 was technically lifted today. The operative word there is ‘technically.’ Pakistan, Pakistanis and Pakistani politics were already in a very troubled state when the emergency was imposed and it is in a far worse condition now. Only someone who has totally missed on everything that has happened over the last month and a half or someone in total denial could even argue that we are back to where we were before the emergency. Pakistan is, in fact, in a much bigger quagmire because of the emergency.

The President claims in his address that “The country has been saved from grave dangers through imposition of emergency.” He is wrong. Unless, of course, he actually believes that he and his person is the country. His Presidency has, in fact, been saved by the emergency. But everything else – democracy, national security, the political fabric, the judiciary, the constitution, media freedom, extremist violence, national morale – has been severely maligned by this emergency. One only prays that the damage inflicted does not turn out to be permanent.

Artwork by AbroThe President also claims that “as promised, PCO has been repealed, emergency lifted and the Constitution restored.” Once again, he is not being fully honest. In fact, he made parts of the PCO permanent and played around (yet again) with the spirit as well as teh substance of the constitution only yesterday. As The News reported in its lead story yesterday:

President Pervez Musharraf on Friday amended various articles of the Constitution providing protection and continuity to the superior courts judges who took oath under the Provisional Constitution Order (PCO), and removed those who did not take oath under the PCO. However, they would be entitled to pension and other retirement benefits.

The amendments were made a day before he intends to lift emergency and restore the Constitution. The president, in exercise of powers under the PCO, has amended Articles 41, 44, 193, 194, 208 and 270-C.

In case, there was any doubt in anyone’s mind the Attorney General made clear that: “Whatever amendments are made in the Constitution do not need ratification from parliament.” This, by the way, the second set of arbitrary and unconstitutional changes to the Constitution in the guise of this emergency.

Artwork by AbroAnd all, one wonders, for what? From the part of his speech targeted to foreign audiences one would assume that the emergency has in some way helped ease the extremism and violence in Swat and the Northern areas. Had that, in fact, been so there would be some mild relief. The fact of the matter is that the emergency only distracted the attention away from that grave situation and the situation there continues to worsen. In fact, the emergency has only strengthened the militants and given them time to organize and mobilize further. Again, all one needs is the daily newspaper to keep abreast of far the government has lost control over militant extremists. For example, from Dawn:

Local Taliban from tribal areas and some districts of the NWFP on Friday decided to set up a centralised organisation for a joint war against US and Nato forces in Afghanistan and appointed Baitullah Mehsud as their Central Amir, a spokesman for the militant commander told Dawn. The militants have named their movement as Tehrik Taliban-i-Pakistan and said the aim of the movement was to enforce Sharia in their respective areas.

The decision was taken at a meeting of 40 Taliban leaders, held in an undisclosed place in South Waziristan Agency. “The sole objective of the Shura meeting was to unite the Taliban against Nato forces in Afghanistan and to wage a ‘defensive jihad’ against Pakistani forces here,” Baitullah’s spokesman Maulvi Omar said. He claimed that Pakistani forces were bombing seminaries and killing people and the Taliban wanted to avenge the forces’ action.

Taliban Police Station in MattaThe meeting asked the government to call off military operation in Swat and North Waziristan and abolish all military checkpoints within 10 days. Otherwise, it warned, a suitable course of action would be chalked out in the next meeting of the militants. Taliban leaders from seven tribal agencies, six Frontier Regions of Fata and NWFP districts of Swat, Kohistan, Buner, Dir, Malakand, Kulachi, Bannu, Lakki Marwat, Tank and D.I. Khan attended the meeting.

They demanded release of Lal Masjid cleric Maulana Abdul Aziz and other Taliban jailed across the country.In another development, Baitullah Mehsud on Friday withdrew his threat to subvert the polls and allowed candidates to run their election campaigns in the South Waziristan. Maulana Hassamuddin and Maulana Mairajuddin, candidates for NA-42, South Waziristan, told Dawn that they had been allowed to take part in the election by Baitullah during their one-to-one meetings with him. Baitullah had earlier written a letter to elders of the Mehsud tribe and asked the candidates to withdraw their nomination papers and warned them of serious consequences if they contested the election.

Note the last paragraph. Those contesting in forthcoming elections had to take permission from the Taliban to do so. Note also the picture we use here. This is a “Taliban Police Station.” If this is not an abdication of national sovereignty by the Musharraf government one wonders what it is!

If there was any doubt at all earlier, it should be clear now that the emergency was for one and one purpose alone. To remove a bunch of judges who seemed to be moving towards a verdict that would not have allowed Gen. Musharraf to remain president. Even in our own highly soiled political history one cannot imagine an instance when such irreparable harm was done to the national polity, to the national psyche and to the national image for such little gain. The last minute changes in the Constitution to keep our some judges proves, as if more proof was needed, that the goal was merely for Gen. Mushrraf to hold on to personal power and office, and no more. Now he has. Good luck to him!

Cartoon by Fauzia MinallahSo, while nothing has been gained (except for him in maintaining personal power) what has been lost is significant. The militant extremists have not only reorganized, re-energized but they have also been reinvigorated by the distraction of “emergency politics.” Two of the most important institutions have been crushed. The emerging assertiveness of the judiciary and the independence of the media have been squashed with venom. A third critical institution – the military – has also suffered a serious blow as the respect for it in society has been gravely damaged. None of us have really ever respected the constitution much, but never have we made as big a joke of it as we have now.

People's Resistance movement in PakistanIt was demonstrated that Pakistan remains a democratic society trapped in an undemocratic state and at least some people have consistently spoken out against what has been happening. But the sad part is that our ‘organized political forces’ have totally let them down. The political fabric has been left asunder.

The political bankruptcy of our supposed political leaders has been further exposed and in their shenanigans for power with Gen. Musharraf all have lost respect – indeed “iss hamam mein sab nangay hain.” Once again one hears the sham cries of those who do not like democracy anyhow (and who mostly do not understand what it really is) that since all the alternatives (Benazir, Nawaz Sharif, etc.) are bad therefore Musharraf should be tolerated. They are wrong. This argument rings even more hollow today than it always has. The politicians remain as full of problems as they always have. What has changed is that Gen. Musharraf has proved that he is no better. Maybe, he is worse.

As you can see, I am in no mood to ‘celebrate’ the supposed ‘lifting’ of the emergency. I do accept, however, that it is good that it is not there. It will also be good if we have elections; even though they will be sham and manipulated elections. It is good. But not good enough. Even if this is a tottering half step forward, the three steps that we have gone backwards means that we remain far worse off than we were at beginning November. What is even more troubling is that all signs suggest that things will become much worse before they become any better.

61 responses to “Emergency “Lifted”: Three Steps Back, Half a Step Forward”

  1. Matloob Zaman says:

    With due regards to distinguished author of this article, do you think you are in a position to revise the following statement at this time? Would you say that it was merely an speculation based on rumors spread by various politicians, parties as well as the media which competently attempted to rig the elections in Pakistan from their very own platform and even after using all those phool jharies they were not able to spark further news material out of the elections event.

    “It will also be good if we have elections; even though they will be sham and manipulated elections.”

  2. Morocco Property says:

    Emergency was only to dissolve supreme court and save presidency

  3. Rahman says:

    Excellent analysis. This is very insightful and honestly written. Excelent.

    You are right we are worse now than we were before the emergency and also that the purpose was only and only to remove some judges for Musharraf’s personal power. Corruption is defined as use of power for personal gain. This is the ultimate corruption, abuse of constitution only to retain a personal office. Now, thsi is what is shameful

  4. The American Desi says:

    A great piece by Naeem Sadiq. make sure all your American buddies read it:

    Breaking News! Proclamation of Emergency and CPO in United States!

    November 3, 2007

    Chief of Staff US Army, General George Tracy today issued a proclamation declaring Emergency, suspending the 1787 US Constitution, dismissing all judges of the superior courts, placing Supreme Court Chief Justice John H Roberts under house arrest, placing a ban on media, and taking away fundamental human rights of all US citizens. He also arrested the President of the American Bar Association William Lukenorm and four other prominent attorneys and sent them to the Guantanamo Bay’s Detention Camp X-Ray. He issued executive orders that despite being a serving military General, he is eligible to contest elections for the post of the President of USA . He then went to the outgoing US Congress and asked them to give him a vote of confidence, if they know what is good for them. He then declared himself the President of USA for next five years. In order to ensure continuity of justice , he reduced the age of judges and picked up sixty odd youngsters , who were duly bribed or coerced to take oath under the new rules made by the Chief of the Army Staff. These rules are called CPO or Chief’s Personal Orders, and these judges referred to as CPO judges.

    Many countries of the world have indicated grave concern over the new developments in USA and expressed hope that General Tracy would soon have the country back on the path of democracy.

    December 15, 2007

    General George Tracy today removed the state of emergency, lifted CPO and restored the US constitution. However before its restoration, the following changes were made to the constitution.
    Actions of declaring the emergency and proclamation of CPO were legal orders and can neither be challenged nor require a ratification by the Congress.
    Actions of sacking all judges and putting them under house were legal orders and can neither be challenged nor require a ratification by the Congress.
    The new judges who took oath under the Chief’s Personal Orders (CPO) are the legal judges of USA and this action can neither be challenged nor requires a ratification by the next Congress.
    A serving military General who has taken oath not to take part in politics and to uphold the constitution can now violate, suspend or amend the constitution in what ever manner he feels like and these actions can neither be challenged nor require a ratification by the Congress.

    Many countries of the world have expressed great satisfaction at the restoration of constitution in USA and have expressed hope that the country would soon be back on the path of full democracy.

    Meanwhile Leaders of Democratic and Republican parties have assured General Tracy of their full support and complete participation in the next general elections scheduled to be held on January 8, 2008.

    (Naeem Sadiq)

  5. Rafay Kashmiri says:


    @ Fellows ! It is great time that we should go for
    those who are killing everyday muslims every where,
    they must be dealt with efficiently, In Pakistan, Army is
    utilised, exploited, and abused in plans where they find
    themselves killing the target which are muslims.
    We have many within our country living but “FOR ”
    someone else. Those have to be taken out of their ‘holes’.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.